Alicyclic Compounds vs. Aromatic Compounds — What's the Difference?
By Tayyaba Rehman — Published on December 12, 2023
Alicyclic Compounds are non-aromatic ring compounds, while Aromatic Compounds contain a planar ring with delocalized π electrons, displaying special stability.
Difference Between Alicyclic Compounds and Aromatic Compounds
Table of Contents
ADVERTISEMENT
Key Differences
Alicyclic Compounds and Aromatic Compounds both belong to the broader category of cyclic organic compounds. However, Alicyclic Compounds resemble aliphatic compounds in their properties and do not possess the special stability associated with aromaticity. They are essentially cyclic but non-aromatic in nature.
Aromatic Compounds, on the other hand, are characterized by the presence of a cyclic, planar structure with a continuous overlapping of p-orbitals, leading to a delocalized π-electron system. This delocalization gives Aromatic Compounds a unique stability, known as aromatic stability, which Alicyclic Compounds lack.
When discussing chemical behavior, Alicyclic Compounds typically react in a manner similar to their open-chain counterparts, exhibiting characteristics of aliphatic compounds. Their reactions are often straightforward, without the special reactivity patterns seen in Aromatic Compounds.
Aromatic Compounds have distinct reactivity patterns, mainly due to the stabilization of the π-electron system. Electrophilic aromatic substitution is a common reaction type for these compounds. In contrast, Alicyclic Compounds won't usually undergo such reactions.
In terms of examples, cyclohexane is an Alicyclic Compound because it doesn't exhibit the properties of aromaticity. Benzene, however, is a classic example of Aromatic Compounds, possessing a six-membered ring with alternating double bonds and showcasing the special stability of aromatics.
ADVERTISEMENT
Comparison Chart
Aromaticity
Non-aromatic
Aromatic
Structure
Cyclic but not planar
Planar with delocalized π electrons
Stability
Normal stability
Enhanced stability due to aromaticity
Typical Reactions
Similar to aliphatic compounds
Electrophilic aromatic substitution
Example
Cyclohexane
Benzene
Compare with Definitions
Alicyclic Compounds
Closed-chain structures not possessing the special stability of aromatic systems.
Unlike benzene, cyclohexane is an Alicyclic Compound and does not have delocalized electrons.
Aromatic Compounds
Substances characterized by cyclic, planar structures with continuous p-orbital overlap.
Toluene, derived from benzene, is another example of Aromatic Compounds.
Alicyclic Compounds
Organic molecules with a ring formation that doesn't exhibit aromatic behaviors.
The lack of alternate double bonds in cyclohexane makes it one of the Alicyclic Compounds.
Aromatic Compounds
Organic molecules with a planar ring and delocalized π electrons, granting special stability.
Benzene, with its six-carbon ring and alternating double bonds, is among the most recognized Aromatic Compounds.
Alicyclic Compounds
Non-aromatic ring compounds devoid of the planar, conjugated structure.
Though cyclobutane is cyclic, it's classified among Alicyclic Compounds due to its lack of aromaticity.
Aromatic Compounds
Organic ring systems exhibiting resonance or conjugation, leading to a stabilized structure.
Phenol, with a hydroxyl group attached to a benzene ring, is a classic representation of Aromatic Compounds.
Alicyclic Compounds
Cyclic compounds resembling properties of aliphatic compounds.
Cyclopentane is an Alicyclic Compound with a five-membered ring.
Aromatic Compounds
Chemical entities that showcase enhanced stability due to a unique electron delocalization in their ring structure.
Naphthalene, with its two fused benzene rings, falls under Aromatic Compounds.
Alicyclic Compounds
Organic substances with a ring structure but without aromatic character.
One of the simplest Alicyclic Compounds is cyclopropane.
Aromatic Compounds
Ring compounds displaying special reactivity patterns due to their aromatic nature.
Aniline, a benzene ring with an amine group, is categorized among Aromatic Compounds.
Common Curiosities
Are Alicyclic Compounds planar like Aromatic Compounds?
No, unlike Aromatic Compounds, Alicyclic Compounds aren't necessarily planar.
Do Alicyclic Compounds possess the special stability seen in Aromatic Compounds?
No, Alicyclic Compounds lack the aromatic stability that Aromatic Compounds display.
Why are Aromatic Compounds particularly stable?
Aromatic Compounds have a delocalized π-electron system across a planar ring, granting them special stability.
Are Aromatic Compounds always hydrocarbons?
No, while many Aromatic Compounds, like benzene, are hydrocarbons, others might contain heteroatoms.
Can Alicyclic Compounds have alternating double bonds like some Aromatic Compounds?
While Alicyclic Compounds can have double bonds, they don't exhibit the special stability of Aromatic Compounds.
Why are Aromatic Compounds named so?
Historically, many Aromatic Compounds were derived from fragrant substances, leading to the term "aromatic."
What's the key distinction between Alicyclic Compounds and Aromatic Compounds?
Alicyclic Compounds are non-aromatic ring compounds, whereas Aromatic Compounds have a planar ring with delocalized π electrons.
Is cyclohexane an example of Aromatic Compounds?
No, cyclohexane is an example of Alicyclic Compounds.
Do Alicyclic Compounds and Aromatic Compounds react in the same way?
No, Alicyclic Compounds have reactions similar to aliphatic compounds, while Aromatic Compounds have unique reactivity patterns.
Can a molecule with a ring always be considered an Aromatic Compound?
No, only those with delocalized π electrons and a planar structure are Aromatic Compounds. Others might be Alicyclic Compounds.
Is benzene the only example of Aromatic Compounds?
No, benzene is a primary example, but there are many other Aromatic Compounds like toluene, naphthalene, etc.
Can an Alicyclic Compound become an Aromatic Compound upon modification?
Theoretically, structural modifications can impart aromatic character to some Alicyclic Compounds, but it depends on the specific compound and change.
Share Your Discovery
Previous Comparison
BJT vs. MOSFET
Next Comparison
NTSC vs. PALAuthor Spotlight
Written by
Tayyaba RehmanTayyaba Rehman is a distinguished writer, currently serving as a primary contributor to askdifference.com. As a researcher in semantics and etymology, Tayyaba's passion for the complexity of languages and their distinctions has found a perfect home on the platform. Tayyaba delves into the intricacies of language, distinguishing between commonly confused words and phrases, thereby providing clarity for readers worldwide.
