Aria vs. Recitative — What's the Difference?
By Tayyaba Rehman — Updated on September 22, 2023
An aria is a melodic, expressive song in an opera, while a recitative is a speech-like, declamatory style of singing that conveys plot and dialogue.
Difference Between Aria and Recitative
Table of Contents
ADVERTISEMENT
Key Differences
An aria is one of the highlights of an opera, presenting a character's emotions and thoughts through a melodic, often virtuosic song. On the other hand, recitative is used to advance the plot, delivering dialogue in a way that's closer to spoken word but still sung.
Arias are meant to showcase the singer's vocal talent, often with elaborate melodies and rich orchestration. Recitative, in contrast, is more straightforward, frequently accompanied by a simple chordal instrument, such as a harpsichord, aiming to relay information or dialogue.
In an opera, it's common for a recitative to precede an aria. The recitative sets the scene or context, and the aria delves deep into a character's emotional response. While both are integral to the operatic form, they serve distinct functions: the aria for emotional reflection and the recitative for narrative progression.
During an aria, time seems to stand still as characters express their innermost feelings. With recitative, the story moves forward, bridging the gaps between the more emotionally charged arias. Together, arias and recitatives create a dynamic ebb and flow, balancing story progression with emotional depth.
Comparison Chart
Purpose
Express emotions and feelings
Advance the plot and convey dialogue
ADVERTISEMENT
Style
Melodic and expressive
Speech-like and declamatory
Accompaniment
Rich orchestration
Often simple, like a harpsichord
Time in Opera
Time "stands still" for reflection
Moves the story forward
Vocal Demand
Showcases vocal virtuosity
More straightforward, less melodic
Compare with Definitions
Aria
A melodic piece in an opera showcasing a singer's emotions.
The soprano delivered a breathtaking aria that left the audience in awe.
Recitative
A style in opera used to progress the story.
The recitative sections kept the opera's momentum going.
Aria
A composition characterized by expressive, often virtuosic singing.
She practiced the challenging aria for weeks.
Recitative
A narrative song in operas that conveys dialogue.
He performed the recitative with clear diction, ensuring the audience understood the plot.
Aria
A segment in an opera where a character reflects on their feelings.
The villain's aria revealed his inner turmoil.
Recitative
The sung equivalent of spoken dialogue in opera.
The transition from recitative to aria was seamless and captivating.
Aria
An elaborate song that contrasts with recitative sections.
After a swift recitative, the aria brought tears to many eyes.
Recitative
A straightforward, often minimally accompanied song in opera.
The sparse accompaniment during the recitative highlighted the singer's voice.
Aria
A standalone song within an operatic performance.
The tenor's aria was the highlight of the evening.
Recitative
A declamatory style of singing in operas resembling speech.
The recitative provided crucial context before the emotional climax.
Aria
In music, an aria ([ˈaːrja]; Italian: air; plural: arie [ˈaːrje], or arias in common usage, diminutive form arietta [aˈrjetta], plural ariette, or in English simply air) is a self-contained piece for one voice, with or without instrumental or orchestral accompaniment, normally part of a larger work. An aria is a formal musical composition unlike its counterpart, the recitative.
Recitative
Recitative (, also known by its Italian name "recitativo" ([retʃitaˈtiːvo])) is a style of delivery (much used in operas, oratorios, and cantatas) in which a singer is allowed to adopt the rhythms and delivery of ordinary speech. Recitative does not repeat lines as formally composed songs do.
Aria
A long accompanied song for a solo voice, typically one in an opera or oratorio.
Recitative
Musical declamation of the kind usual in the narrative and dialogue parts of opera and oratorio, sung in the rhythm of ordinary speech with many words on the same note
Singing in recitative
Aria
A solo vocal piece with instrumental accompaniment, as in an opera.
Recitative
Of, relating to, or having the character of a recital or recitation.
Aria
An air; a melody.
Recitative
A style used in operas, oratorios, and cantatas in which the text is declaimed in the rhythm of natural speech with slight melodic variation and little orchestral accompaniment.
Aria
(music) A musical piece written typically for a solo voice with orchestral accompaniment in an opera or cantata.
Recitative
A passage rendered in this style. In both senses also called recitativo.
Aria
An air or song; a melody; a tune.
Recitative
(music) dialogue, in an opera etc, that, rather than being sung as an aria, is reproduced with the rhythms of normal speech, often with simple musical accompaniment or harpsichord continuo, serving to expound the plot.
In Gilbert and Sullivan's Patience, Bunthorne performs the recitative "Am I Alone and Unobserved?" before going on to his solo aria "If You're Anxious For To Shine".
Aria
An elaborate song for solo voice
Recitative
Of a recital
Aria
An elaborate song for solo voice
Recitative
A species of musical recitation in which the words are delivered in a manner resembling that of ordinary declamation; also, a piece of music intended for such recitation; - opposed to melisma.
Recitative
Of or pertaining to recitation; intended for musical recitation or declamation; in the style or manner of recitative.
Recitative
A vocal passage of narrative text that a singer delivers with natural rhythms of speech
Common Curiosities
How does a recitative function in an opera?
A recitative advances the plot and conveys dialogue in a speech-like style.
Can an aria be performed outside of an opera?
Yes, arias can be standalone pieces and are often performed in concerts.
Are recitatives typically melodic?
No, recitatives are more speech-like and less melodic than arias.
How long are arias in comparison to recitatives?
Arias are generally longer, while recitatives are brief and concise.
Are arias and recitatives exclusive to opera?
Primarily, yes, but they can also be found in other vocal works like oratorios.
Why do arias receive more attention than recitatives?
Arias showcase vocal virtuosity and are often the memorable highlights of an opera.
What is the main purpose of an aria?
An aria expresses a character's emotions and reflections in a melodic manner.
Which comes first in an opera, the aria or recitative?
Typically, a recitative precedes an aria to set the context.
Why do arias often have rich orchestration?
Rich orchestration in arias enhances the emotional depth and expressiveness of the piece.
What instruments typically accompany recitatives?
Recitatives are often accompanied by simple instruments like the harpsichord.
Why are recitatives important if they're less melodic?
Recitatives drive the narrative forward, bridging between the more emotive arias.
Do arias always express sad emotions?
No, arias can express a range of emotions from joy to despair.
Can a singer specialize in recitatives?
While singers must master both, they typically aren't known solely for recitative performance.
Do all operas contain both arias and recitatives?
Most traditional operas do, but it varies based on the composer and style of the opera.
Are there different types of recitatives?
Yes, such as "secco" (dry, with minimal accompaniment) and "accompagnato" (with orchestral accompaniment).
Share Your Discovery
Previous Comparison
Pilchard vs. Sardine
Next Comparison
Fantastic vs. FantasticalAuthor Spotlight
Written by
Tayyaba RehmanTayyaba Rehman is a distinguished writer, currently serving as a primary contributor to askdifference.com. As a researcher in semantics and etymology, Tayyaba's passion for the complexity of languages and their distinctions has found a perfect home on the platform. Tayyaba delves into the intricacies of language, distinguishing between commonly confused words and phrases, thereby providing clarity for readers worldwide.
