Broil vs. Roast — What's the Difference?
By Tayyaba Rehman & Fiza Rafique — Updated on March 12, 2024
Broiling uses direct radiant heat from above, while roasting involves indirect heat, surrounding the food in an oven.
Difference Between Broil and Roast
Table of Contents
ADVERTISEMENT
Key Differences
Broiling is a cooking method that employs direct radiant heat from an overhead source, cooking food quickly at high temperatures. This technique is ideal for foods that cook within a short period, like thin cuts of meat, vegetables, or fish, creating a caramelized, crispy exterior. Roasting, on the other hand, uses indirect, dry heat from an oven, where the hot air envelops the food, cooking it evenly on all sides. It's suited for larger, denser foods such as whole poultry, large cuts of meat, or root vegetables, often resulting in a tender interior and a browned exterior.
The positioning of food in relation to the heat source is crucial in broiling; food is placed close to the heat element in the oven's top part, exposing it to intense direct heat. In contrast, during roasting, food is placed in the middle of the oven, allowing the hot air to circulate around it for even cooking. This difference in heat application makes broiling much faster than roasting, which takes longer due to the gentle, all-around heat.
Broiling typically doesn't require added fat, as the high heat quickly sears the food, locking in juices and creating a flavorful charred surface. Roasting, however, may involve basting or coating the food in oil or fat to enhance flavor, maintain moisture, and encourage browning and crisping of the exterior.
The choice between broiling and roasting often depends on the desired outcome. Broiling is preferred for a quick sear or char, perfect for adding texture and flavor to the surface of the food. Roasting is chosen for depth of flavor and tenderness, especially for dishes that benefit from slow, even cooking, allowing flavors to develop fully.
Both broiling and roasting are popular cooking methods, each offering distinct textures, flavors, and culinary experiences. While broiling provides a quick, flavorful sear, roasting is ideal for achieving tenderness and complex flavors in a variety of dishes.
ADVERTISEMENT
Comparison Chart
Heat Source
Direct radiant heat from above
Indirect heat, surrounding the food
Ideal Foods
Thin cuts of meat, fish, vegetables
Larger cuts of meat, whole poultry, root vegetables
Cooking Time
Short, due to high heat
Longer, due to moderate heat
Position in Oven
Close to the top heat element
In the middle of the oven
Texture Outcome
Caramelized and crispy exterior
Tender interior with a browned exterior
Compare with Definitions
Broil
Uses direct overhead radiant heat for quick cooking.
Broiling a salmon fillet for a crispy top.
Roast
Utilizes indirect dry heat for even cooking.
Roasting a turkey for a holiday meal.
Broil
Requires minimal to no added fat.
Broiling chicken breasts without additional oil for a healthy option.
Roast
Suited for large, dense foods.
Roasting a beef joint for Sunday dinner.
Broil
Ideal for thin cuts of meat or vegetables.
Broiled asparagus with a charred edge.
Roast
Yields a tender interior with a browned exterior.
Roasted root vegetables with a soft inside and caramelized outside.
Broil
Produces a seared, caramelized surface.
Broiled steak with a flavorful charred crust.
Roast
Often involves basting or oiling for flavor and moisture.
Roasting potatoes with olive oil for a crispy exterior.
Broil
Food is placed close to the heat source for intense heat exposure.
Placing peppers near the broiler for quick blistering.
Roast
Food is cooked with surrounding hot air, allowing for even heat distribution.
Roasting a whole chicken in the middle of the oven.
Broil
Cook (meat or fish) by exposure to direct heat
A broiled sirloin steak
He lightly broiled a wedge of sea bass
Roast
Cook (food, especially meat) by prolonged exposure to heat in an oven or over a fire
She was going to roast a leg of mutton for Sunday dinner
Broil
A quarrel or commotion
The dark interior was a broil of fighting men
Roast
Criticize or reprimand severely
If you waste his time he'll roast you
Broil
To cook by direct radiant heat, as over a grill or under an electric element.
Roast
(of food) having been roasted
A plate of cold roast beef
Broil
To expose to great heat.
Roast
A joint of meat that has been roasted or that is intended for roasting
Carving the Sunday roast
Broil
To be exposed to great heat.
Roast
A banquet at which the guest of honour is subjected to good-natured ridicule.
Broil
To engage in a rowdy argument.
Roast
To cook with dry heat, as in an oven or near hot coals.
Broil
The act of broiling or the condition of being broiled.
Roast
To dry, brown, or parch by exposing to heat.
Broil
Food, especially meat, that is broiled.
Roast
To expose to great or excessive heat.
Broil
A rowdy argument.
Roast
(Metallurgy) To heat (ores) in a furnace in order to dehydrate, purify, or oxidize before smelting.
Broil
To cook by direct, radiant heat.
Roast
To ridicule or criticize harshly.
Broil
To expose to great heat.
Roast
To honor at or subject to a roast.
Broil
To be exposed to great heat.
Roast
To cook food in an oven.
Broil
(transitive) To cause a rowdy disturbance; embroil.
Roast
To undergo roasting.
Broil
To brawl.
Roast
Something roasted.
Broil
Food prepared by broiling.
Roast
A cut of meat suitable or prepared for roasting.
Broil
(archaic) A brawl; a rowdy disturbance.
Come to broils
Roast
The act or process of roasting.
Broil
A tumult; a noisy quarrel; a disturbance; a brawl; contention; discord, either between individuals or in the state.
I will own that there is a haughtiness and fierceness in human nature which will which will cause innumerable broils, place men in what situation you please.
Roast
The state of being roasted.
Broil
To cook by direct exposure to heat over a fire, esp. upon a gridiron over coals.
Roast
Harsh ridicule or criticism.
Broil
To subject to great (commonly direct) heat.
Roast
A facetious tribute, as at a banquet, in which the honoree is alternately praised and insulted.
Broil
To be subjected to the action of heat, as meat over the fire; to be greatly heated, or to be made uncomfortable with heat.
The planets and comets had been broiling in the sun.
Roast
Roasted
Roast duck.
Broil
Cooking by direct exposure to radiant heat (as over a fire or under a grill)
Roast
To cook food by heating in an oven or over a fire without covering, resulting in a crisp, possibly even slightly charred appearance.
To roast meat on a spit
Broil
Cook under a broiler;
Broil fish
Roast
To cook by surrounding with hot embers, ashes, sand, etc.
To roast a potato in ashes
Broil
Heat by a natural force;
The sun broils the valley in the summer
Roast
To process by drying through exposure to sun or artificial heat.
Coffee beans need roasting before use.
To roast chestnuts or peanuts
Roast
To heat to excess; to heat violently; to burn.
Roast
To admonish someone vigorously.
I'm late home for the fourth time this week; my mate will really roast me this time.
Roast
To subject to bantering, severely criticize, sometimes as a comedy routine.
The class clown enjoys being roasted by mates as well as staff.
Roast
(metalworking) To dissipate the volatile parts of by heat, as ores.
Roast
A cut of meat suited to roasting; meat that has been roasted.
Serve the roast with gravy and mashed potatoes.
Roast
A meal consisting of roast foods.
Come over this weekend for Sunday roast.
Roast
The degree to which something, especially coffee, is roasted.
Dark roast means that the coffee bean has been roasted to a higher temperature and for a longer period of time than in light roast.
Roast
An instance of being severely admonished, criticized, roasted.
Roast
A comical event, originally fraternal, where a person is subjected to verbal attack, yet may be praised by sarcasm and jokes.
Roast
(North America) A social event at which food is roasted and eaten.
On Memorial Day we hosted a wiener roast in the backyard.
Roast
(slang) A creative insult as a response to something someone said.
Roast
Having been cooked by roasting.
Roast
(figuratively) Subjected to roasting; bantered; severely criticized. en
Roast
To cook by exposure to radiant heat before a fire; as, to roast meat on a spit, or in an oven open toward the fire and having reflecting surfaces within; also, to cook in a close oven.
Roast
To cook by surrounding with hot embers, ashes, sand, etc.; as, to roast a potato in ashes.
In eggs boiled and roasted there is scarce difference to be discerned.
Roast
To dry and parch by exposure to heat; as, to roast coffee; to roast chestnuts, or peanuts.
Roast
Hence, to heat to excess; to heat violently; to burn.
Roast
To dissipate by heat the volatile parts of, as ores.
Roast
To banter severely.
Roast
To cook meat, fish, etc., by heat, as before the fire or in an oven.
He could roast, and seethe, and broil, and fry.
Roast
To undergo the process of being roasted.
Roast
That which is roasted; a piece of meat which has been roasted, or is suitable for being roasted.
A fat swan loved he best of any roost [roast].
Roast
Roasted; as, roast beef.
Roast
A piece of meat roasted or for roasting and of a size for slicing into more than one portion
Roast
Negative criticism
Roast
Cook with dry heat, usually in an oven;
Roast the turkey
Roast
Subject to laughter or ridicule;
The satirists ridiculed the plans for a new opera house
The students poked fun at the inexperienced teacher
His former students roasted the professor at his 60th birthday
Roast
(of meat) cooked by dry heat in an oven
Common Curiosities
What is broiling in cooking?
Broiling is a cooking method using direct overhead radiant heat to quickly cook and char the surface of the food.
How does broiling differ from grilling?
Broiling and grilling both use direct heat, but broiling uses overhead heat in an oven, while grilling uses heat from below, often over an open flame.
What foods are best suited for broiling?
Foods best for broiling include thin cuts of meat, fish, and vegetables that can cook quickly under high heat.
Can you broil with an electric oven?
Yes, electric ovens often have a broil setting that uses the top element to provide direct radiant heat.
What's the difference between baking and roasting?
Baking and roasting both use dry heat; however, roasting is typically at higher temperatures and is used for meats and vegetables, whereas baking is associated with breads, pastries, and casseroles.
Can vegetables be roasted and broiled?
Yes, vegetables can be both roasted and broiled, depending on the desired texture and flavor; broiling will give them a char, while roasting will make them tender and caramelized.
What kitchen equipment is essential for broiling and roasting?
A broiler pan or baking sheet is essential for broiling, and a roasting pan or oven-safe dish is needed for roasting.
What is the main advantage of roasting?
The main advantage of roasting is its ability to cook food evenly, making it ideal for larger and denser foods, resulting in a tender interior and browned exterior.
Why is preheating important for both broiling and roasting?
Preheating ensures the oven reaches the correct temperature for immediate, even cooking, crucial for achieving the desired texture and flavor in both methods.
How can you prevent food from drying out when roasting?
Basting the food with its juices or a marinade, or coating it in oil or fat, can help maintain moisture during roasting.
Can I roast without an oven?
Traditional roasting requires an oven for even heat distribution, but alternative methods like using a covered grill or a slow cooker can mimic roasting conditions.
Is it necessary to flip food when broiling?
Yes, flipping food during broiling ensures even charring and cooking on both sides.
How do I know when broiled food is done?
Broiled food is done when it has a charred or browned surface and reaches the desired internal temperature, as checked with a food thermometer.
Can marinating improve the results of broiling and roasting?
Yes, marinating can add flavor and moisture, enhancing the results of both broiling and roasting.
How can I avoid smoke when broiling?
To avoid smoke, keep the oven door slightly ajar, use a drip pan to catch fats, and ensure the food is not too close to the heat source.
Share Your Discovery
Previous Comparison
Uneducated vs. Undereducated
Next Comparison
Perceptivity vs. PerceptivenessAuthor Spotlight
Written by
Tayyaba RehmanTayyaba Rehman is a distinguished writer, currently serving as a primary contributor to askdifference.com. As a researcher in semantics and etymology, Tayyaba's passion for the complexity of languages and their distinctions has found a perfect home on the platform. Tayyaba delves into the intricacies of language, distinguishing between commonly confused words and phrases, thereby providing clarity for readers worldwide.
Co-written by
Fiza RafiqueFiza Rafique is a skilled content writer at AskDifference.com, where she meticulously refines and enhances written pieces. Drawing from her vast editorial expertise, Fiza ensures clarity, accuracy, and precision in every article. Passionate about language, she continually seeks to elevate the quality of content for readers worldwide.
