Butterfish vs. Pomfret — What's the Difference?
By Tayyaba Rehman & Maham Liaqat — Updated on April 6, 2024
Butterfish are small, oily fish known for their soft texture, while pomfret refers to a family of marine fish valued for their flat bodies and flavorful flesh.
Difference Between Butterfish and Pomfret
Table of Contents
ADVERTISEMENT
Key Differences
Butterfish and pomfret are both popular seafood choices, each with unique characteristics that set them apart. Butterfish, known for their small size and oily nature, are celebrated for their delicate, buttery texture, making them a favorite among those who prefer soft, easily digestible fish. Pomfret, on the other hand, encompasses a variety of species within the family Bramidae, distinguished by their flat bodies and deeply forked tails. These fish are often praised for their mild, yet distinctly flavorful flesh, making them a sought-after choice in many culinary traditions.
While butterfish have a high oil content, which contributes to their rich flavor and soft texture, pomfret are generally leaner, with a texture that is firm yet flaky when cooked. This difference in fat content not only affects the taste and texture but also influences the cooking methods suitable for each fish. Butterfish are often grilled or pan-fried to enhance their natural flavors, whereas pomfret can be cooked in a variety of ways, including baking, grilling, and steaming, making them a versatile ingredient in kitchens around the world.
The habitat of these fish also differs, with butterfish typically found in warmer waters around the world, contributing to their wide availability and popularity in various cuisines. Pomfret, though also found in warm waters, are especially prevalent in the Indian and Pacific Oceans, where they are integral to the culinary practices of the regions. This geographical distinction plays a significant role in the cultural significance and culinary uses of each fish.
In terms of nutrition, both butterfish and pomfret offer a good source of protein and essential nutrients. However, the higher oil content in butterfish means they are also rich in omega-3 fatty acids, beneficial for heart health. Pomfret, while leaner, still provides a healthy option with its high protein content and a considerable amount of omega-3 fatty acids, though in lesser quantities compared to butterfish.
Culinary preferences for one over the other often depend on personal taste, dietary needs, and cultural background. Butterfish, with their rich, oily texture, are often favored for their heartiness, while pomfret is preferred for its delicate flavor and versatility in cooking.
ADVERTISEMENT
Comparison Chart
Size & Texture
Small and oily with a soft texture.
Larger, with a firm yet flaky texture when cooked.
Flavor
Rich and buttery.
Mild and flavorful.
Fat Content
High oil content, rich in omega-3 fatty acids.
Leaner, with moderate amounts of omega-3 fatty acids.
Cooking Methods
Best grilled or pan-fried.
Versatile: can be baked, grilled, or steamed.
Habitat
Warm waters globally.
Primarily in the Indian and Pacific Oceans.
Compare with Definitions
Butterfish
A small, oily fish celebrated for its delicate texture.
The chef prepared the butterfish with minimal seasoning to highlight its natural flavor.
Pomfret
A family of marine fish known for their flat bodies and flavorful flesh.
Pomfret is often the fish of choice for special occasions due to its exquisite taste.
Butterfish
Rich in omega-3 fatty acids, making it a healthy choice.
For a heart-healthy diet, consider adding butterfish to your meals.
Pomfret
Features a firm texture that becomes flaky when cooked.
The chef expertly cooked the pomfret to achieve the perfect flaky texture.
Butterfish
Popular in various cuisines for its rich flavor.
Butterfish is a staple in many coastal dishes, prized for its taste.
Pomfret
Versatile in cooking methods, including baking and steaming.
Steamed pomfret with ginger and soy sauce is a classic dish.
Butterfish
Often grilled or pan-fried to enhance its flavor.
Grilled butterfish with a dash of lemon is a simple yet delicious meal.
Pomfret
Found mainly in the Indian and Pacific Oceans, integral to regional cuisines.
In coastal regions, pomfret is often used in traditional recipes passed down through generations.
Butterfish
Known for its soft, buttery flesh.
Butterfish melts in your mouth like butter, hence the name.
Pomfret
A good source of protein and omega-3 fatty acids.
Including pomfret in your diet provides nutritional benefits along with flavor.
Butterfish
Any of various fishes of the family Stromateidae having tender oily flesh, especially Peprilus triacanthus of the North American Atlantic coast.
Pomfret
Pomfrets are perciform fishes belonging to the family Bramidae. The family currently includes 20 species across seven genera.
Butterfish
Any of various other fishes having oily flesh or slippery skin.
Pomfret
Either of two butterfishes of the Indian and Pacific Oceans, Pampus argenteus or P. chinensis.
Butterfish
Any of various species of fish having a slippery mucous coating, especially
Pomfret
Any of various edible marine fishes of the family Bramidae, having a blunt head and a compressed, usually black body.
Butterfish
Perciform fish of the family Stromateidae, including the genera Pampus, Peprilus and Stromateus.
Pomfret
A fish of family Bramidae, consisting of eight genera and some twenty species.
Butterfish
A rock gunnel, Pholis gunnellus, an eel-like fish found in the intertidal and subtidal zones of the North Atlantic.
Pomfret
Any of several species of butterfishes in the genus Pampus.
Butterfish
The New Zealand fish Odax pullus, also known as greenbone.
Pomfret
The golden pomfret, Trachinotus blochii.
Butterfish
(obsolete) The Murray perch, Oligorus mitchelli; an Australian perciform fish of Murray river, now known as trout cod, Maccullochella macquariensis [http://www.fishbase.org/Nomenclature/SynonymsList.php?ID=6308&SynCode=26048&GenusName=Maccullochella&SpeciesName=macquariensis], [http://www.fishbase.org/summary/Maccullochella-macquariensis.html].
Pomfret
The black pomfret, Parastromateus niger.
Butterfish
(informal) The sablefish (Anoplopoma fimbria) the sablefish is not a true butterfish; but is called such informally
Pomfret
One of two or more species of marine food fishes of the genus Stromateus (Stromateus niger, Stromateus argenteus) native of Southern Europe and Asia.
Butterfish
A name given to several different fishes, in allusion to their slippery coating of mucus, as the Stromateus triacanthus of the Atlantic coast, the Epinephelus punctatus of the southern coast, the rock eel, and the kelpfish of New Zealand.
Pomfret
Deep-bodied sooty-black pelagic spiny-finned fish of the northern Atlantic and northern Pacific; valued for food
Butterfish
Any of numerous small flat Atlantic food fish having smooth skin
Butterfish
Small marine fish with a short smooth-scaled compressed body and feeble spines
Butterfish
Slippery scaleless food fish of the northern Atlantic coastal waters
Common Curiosities
What is butterfish good for?
Butterfish is good for dishes where a soft, buttery texture and a rich flavor are desired, and it's also high in omega-3 fatty acids.
Can you eat the skin of pomfret?
Yes, the skin of pomfret can be eaten and is often considered flavorful, especially when crisped during cooking.
Is butterfish expensive?
The price of butterfish can vary depending on availability and region, but it is generally affordable compared to other oily fish.
Is there a best season to buy butterfish or pomfret?
The availability and quality of butterfish and pomfret can vary seasonally, with many preferring to buy during cooler months for freshness.
Why is pomfret popular in Asian cuisines?
Pomfret is popular in Asian cuisines due to its mild yet flavorful flesh, which complements the rich, diverse flavors of Asian cooking.
How do you store fresh butterfish or pomfret?
Both should be stored in the coldest part of the refrigerator and ideally cooked within 1-2 days of purchase for optimal freshness.
How do you identify a butterfish?
Butterfish are small, have a high oil content, and a distinct, soft texture that feels buttery when eaten.
What are the best cooking methods for pomfret?
Pomfret can be baked, grilled, steamed, or fried, making it a versatile fish for various recipes.
How do cultural preferences influence the choice between butterfish and pomfret?
Cultural preferences and culinary traditions significantly influence the choice, with pomfret favored in Asian cuisines and butterfish in Western dishes.
How do butterfish and pomfret differ nutritionally?
Butterfish tend to be higher in omega-3 fatty acids due to their oily nature, while pomfret is leaner but still a good source of protein and omega-3s.
Can butterfish be substituted for pomfret in recipes?
While they have different textures and flavors, butterfish can sometimes be substituted for pomfret in recipes, depending on the dish and desired outcome.
Are there different types of pomfret?
Yes, there are several types of pomfret, including black pomfret, white pomfret, and silver pomfret, each with unique characteristics.
What are the health benefits of eating pomfret?
Pomfret offers health benefits including high-quality protein, omega-3 fatty acids, and essential nutrients, supporting heart and overall health.
Share Your Discovery
Previous Comparison
Topup vs. Recharge
Next Comparison
Comedy vs. SitcomAuthor Spotlight
Written by
Tayyaba RehmanTayyaba Rehman is a distinguished writer, currently serving as a primary contributor to askdifference.com. As a researcher in semantics and etymology, Tayyaba's passion for the complexity of languages and their distinctions has found a perfect home on the platform. Tayyaba delves into the intricacies of language, distinguishing between commonly confused words and phrases, thereby providing clarity for readers worldwide.
Co-written by
Maham Liaqat
