Capricious vs. Cruel — What's the Difference?
By Tayyaba Rehman — Updated on September 27, 2023
Capricious describes someone or something that's unpredictable or impulsive, while cruel refers to causing pain or suffering deliberately. Both words reflect behavior, but with different motives and outcomes.
Difference Between Capricious and Cruel
Table of Contents
ADVERTISEMENT
Key Differences
Capricious is a term that characterizes actions or behaviors that are impulsive, unpredictable, or whimsical. On the other hand, cruel is a descriptor for actions that intentionally inflict pain, harm, or suffering upon others. While capricious decisions might be made on a whim, cruel decisions are often made with malevolent intent.
A capricious individual might change their mind frequently, making decisions based on fleeting feelings or sudden impulses. Contrastingly, a cruel individual might act with deliberate malice, intending to hurt or demean others. The unpredictability of capricious actions doesn't necessarily carry malicious intent, unlike cruelty.
It's important to note that while a capricious act might inadvertently cause harm due to its unpredictability, it isn't driven by a desire to cause harm. In contrast, cruel actions are characterized by the intent to cause harm, pain, or suffering, whether physically or emotionally.
One might describe weather patterns as capricious when they change without clear reason, but one wouldn't label them cruel unless emphasizing their devastating effects metaphorically. Conversely, calling someone cruel directly addresses their harmful actions or intentions.
In essence, capriciousness is about erratic behavior or changes without clear motivations, while cruelty is grounded in malevolence and the desire to harm or degrade others.
ADVERTISEMENT
Comparison Chart
Definition
Unpredictable or impulsive behavior
Deliberate infliction of pain or suffering
Intent
Lacks consistent reason or motivation
Intent to cause harm or suffering
Outcome
Results can vary due to unpredictability
Usually results in harm or distress
Usage in Context
Often used for whimsical or erratic decisions
Used for actions with malevolent intent
Associated Feelings
Might induce confusion or unpredictability
Evokes feelings of pain, harm, or malevolence
Compare with Definitions
Capricious
Governed by impulse rather than reason.
Her capricious nature made her unpredictable.
Cruel
Deliberately causing pain or suffering.
The cruel tyrant oppressed his subjects.
Capricious
Marked by erratic behavior or unpredictability.
His capricious decisions often left his team bewildered.
Cruel
Marked by an indifference to the pain of others.
The cruel joke hurt her feelings deeply.
Capricious
Characterized by whimsical or fleeting feelings.
She had a capricious desire for ice cream in the middle of the night.
Cruel
Enjoying the pain or distress of others.
He had a cruel sense of humor that few appreciated.
Capricious
Lacking a consistent or logical pattern.
The capricious market trends were hard to predict.
Cruel
Lacking in compassion or sympathy.
It's cruel to mock someone's misfortunes.
Capricious
Subject to sudden and unaccountable changes of mood.
The capricious winds shifted direction without warning.
Cruel
Disposed to inflict pain or suffering
A cruel tyrant.
Capricious
Characterized by, arising from, or subject to caprice; impulsive or unpredictable
Capricious decisions.
Capricious weather.
Cruel
Causing or characterized by severe pain, suffering, or distress
Cruel treatment.
A cruel remark.
Capricious
Impulsive and unpredictable; determined by chance, impulse, or whim.
I almost died in a capricious winter storm.
Stringent rulers are unlikely to act capriciously.
Cruel
Intentionally causing or reveling in pain and suffering; merciless, heartless.
The supervisor was very cruel to Josh, as he would always give Josh the hardest, most degrading work he could find.
Capricious
Governed or characterized by caprice; apt to change suddenly; freakish; whimsical; changeable.
A capricious partiality to the Romish practices.
Cruel
Harsh; severe.
Capricious
Changeable;
A capricious summer breeze
Freakish weather
Cruel
(slang) Cool; awesome; neat.
Capricious
Determined by chance or impulse or whim rather than by necessity or reason;
A capricious refusal
Authoritarian rulers are frequently capricious
The victim of whimsical persecutions
Cruel
(nonstandard) To a great degree; terribly.
Cruel
To spoil or ruin (one's chance of success)
Cruel
To violently provoke (a child) in the belief that this will make them more assertive.
Cruel
See Crewel.
Cruel
Disposed to give pain to others; willing or pleased to hurt, torment, or afflict; destitute of sympathetic kindness and pity; savage; inhuman; hard-hearted; merciless.
Behold a people cometh from the north country; . . . they are cruel and have no mercy.
Cruel
Causing, or fitted to cause, pain, grief, or misery.
Cruel wars, wasting the earth.
Cursed be their anger, for it was fierce; and their wrath for it was cruel.
Cruel
Attended with cruetly; painful; harsh.
You have seen cruel proof of this man's strength.
Cruel
Lacking or showing kindness or compassion or mercy
Cruel
(of persons or their actions) able or disposed to inflict pain or suffering;
A barbarous crime
Brutal beatings
Cruel tortures
Stalin's roughshod treatment of the kulaks
A savage slap
Vicious kicks
Cruel
(of weapons or instruments) causing suffering and pain;
Brutal instruments of torture
Cruel weapons of war
Cruel
Used of circumstances (especially weather) that cause suffering;
Brutal weather
Northern winters can be cruel
A cruel world
A harsh climate
A rigorous climate
Unkind winters
Cruel
Harsh, severe, or unrelenting.
The cruel winter took a toll on the crops.
Common Curiosities
What does capricious mean?
Capricious describes behavior that's impulsive, unpredictable, or whimsical.
Is capriciousness always negative?
Not necessarily; it simply indicates unpredictability, which can be positive, neutral, or negative based on context.
Can a decision be both capricious and cruel?
Yes, if a decision is made impulsively and results in intentional harm, it can be both.
Why is cruelty considered morally wrong?
Because it involves causing intentional harm or suffering to others, which is ethically and socially condemnable.
Does capriciousness have a root in emotion?
It can, as capricious actions might arise from fleeting feelings or impulses.
What's the opposite of cruel?
Kind or compassionate.
How does cruel differ from capricious?
While capricious indicates unpredictability, cruel refers to intentional infliction of pain or harm.
Are capricious decisions always without reason?
They might have a reason, but it's often not consistent or easily discernible.
Is being cruel the same as being mean?
While similar, cruelty usually indicates a stronger intent to harm or demean than simply being mean.
Is capricious behavior typical in children?
It can be, as children are still developing decision-making skills and can act on whims.
Can an act be cruel without physical harm?
Yes, emotional or psychological cruelty can be as damaging as physical harm.
Can nature be described as capricious?
Yes, when referring to unpredictable changes in weather or natural events.
What might cause capricious behavior in an individual?
Factors like mood swings, impulsiveness, or certain personality traits can lead to capricious behavior.
Can a joke be considered cruel?
Yes, if it intentionally mocks or hurts someone, it's cruel.
How can one address cruel behavior in others?
By confronting the individual, seeking mediation, or providing education on empathy and kindness.
Share Your Discovery
Previous Comparison
Opposite vs. Contrary
Next Comparison
Shinobi vs. SamuraiAuthor Spotlight
Written by
Tayyaba RehmanTayyaba Rehman is a distinguished writer, currently serving as a primary contributor to askdifference.com. As a researcher in semantics and etymology, Tayyaba's passion for the complexity of languages and their distinctions has found a perfect home on the platform. Tayyaba delves into the intricacies of language, distinguishing between commonly confused words and phrases, thereby providing clarity for readers worldwide.
