Civilization vs. Barbarism — What's the Difference?
By Tayyaba Rehman & Urooj Arif — Updated on May 7, 2024
Civilization refers to advanced state of human society with structured government, culture, and technology; barbarism suggests a lack of civilization, often characterized by extreme cruelty or primitive conditions.
Difference Between Civilization and Barbarism
Table of Contents
ADVERTISEMENT
Key Differences
Civilization encompasses societies with complex institutions, technology, and cultural achievements, promoting stability and growth. Whereas barbarism often denotes a state perceived as less culturally and technologically advanced, typically characterized by brutality or a lack of refined societal structures.
In historical contexts, civilizations are noted for their contributions to art, science, and governance, such as Ancient Egypt or Rome. On the other hand, societies labeled as barbaric by these civilizations often lacked formal systems of writing or structured governance, though they might have had rich oral traditions and social orders.
Civilization is often associated with moral progress, including laws and ethics that aim to uphold human rights and dignity. Conversely, barbarism is frequently linked to acts of cruelty, lawlessness, and the violation of these principles, though this can be a subjective interpretation.
In literature and philosophy, civilization is sometimes critiqued for imposing conformity and suppressing individual freedoms. In contrast, barbarism, despite its negative connotations, is occasionally romanticized as a symbol of freedom from societal constraints and a return to natural human instincts.
The concept of civilization can be used to justify imperial and colonial domination, portraying the colonizers as bearers of progress to barbaric lands. Barbarism, in this context, is used pejoratively to describe those colonized peoples, underscoring their supposed need for external governance.
ADVERTISEMENT
Comparison Chart
Definition
Advanced stages of human society with organized structures.
Lack of civilization, often associated with cruelty.
Historical Impact
Led to significant cultural, technological, and scientific advancements.
Often used to describe societies viewed as primitive or cruel.
Ethical Connotations
Associated with moral progress and human rights.
Linked to cruelty, chaos, and ethical degradation.
Literary Usage
Critiqued for potential suppression of freedoms.
Sometimes romanticized as a purer state of human existence.
Political Usage
Used to justify imperialism and colonialism.
Used to denigrate and control colonized peoples.
Compare with Definitions
Civilization
The process by which a society achieves an advanced stage of development and organization.
The civilization of the island progressed rapidly after the introduction of new technologies.
Barbarism
The condition of being crude, uneducated, or backward.
The conquerors regarded the local customs as barbarism.
Civilization
The culture, knowledge, and sophistication obtained by a society.
The museum exhibits artifacts from the civilization of the Nile Valley.
Barbarism
The state of society without culture or agriculture.
Some anthropologists study regions that were once in a state of barbarism.
Civilization
Refinement of thought, manners, or taste.
His demeanor and speech reflect a high degree of civilization.
Barbarism
Acts or ideologies that are savagely cruel or harsh.
The novel explores themes of civilization and barbarism.
Civilization
The comfort and convenience of modern life.
After weeks in the wilderness, returning to civilization was a relief.
Barbarism
Lack of refinement or cultural advancement.
He criticized the new policy as a step back into barbarism.
Civilization
A complex human society with established institutions and urban development.
Ancient Mesopotamia is considered one of the earliest civilizations.
Barbarism
Extreme cruelty or brutality.
The history book detailed the barbarism inflicted during the war.
Civilization
A civilization (or civilisation) is a complex society that is characterized by urban development, social stratification, a form of government, and symbolic systems of communication (such as writing).Civilizations are intimately associated with and often further defined by other socio-politico-economic characteristics, such as centralization, the domestication of both humans and other organisms, specialization of labour, culturally-ingrained ideologies of progress and supremacism, monumental architecture, taxation, societal dependence upon farming and expansionism.Historically, "a civilization" has often been understood as a larger and "more advanced" culture, in implied contrast to smaller, supposedly primitive cultures. In this broad sense, a civilization contrasts with non-centralized tribal societies, including the cultures of nomadic pastoralists, Neolithic societies or hunter-gatherers; however, sometimes it also contrasts with the cultures found within civilizations themselves.
Barbarism
The condition of having no civilizing influences or refined culture; ignorance or crudity
"the struggles made by different nations, as they emerge from barbarism, to supply themselves with some visible symbol of thought" (William Hickling Prescott).
Civilization
An advanced state of intellectual, cultural, and material development in human society, marked by progress in the arts and sciences, the extensive use of record-keeping, including writing, and the appearance of complex political and social institutions.
Barbarism
Savage violence or cruelty
"To say that the barbarism of one side [in World War I] impelled the barbarism of the other is not much of an excuse" (David A. Bell).
Civilization
The type of culture and society developed by a particular nation or region or in a particular epoch
Mayan civilization.
The civilization of ancient Rome.
Barbarism
The use of words, forms, or expressions considered incorrect or unacceptable.
Civilization
The act or process of civilizing or reaching a civilized state.
Barbarism
A specific word, form, or expression so used.
Civilization
Cultural or intellectual refinement; good taste.
Barbarism
A barbaric act.
These barbarisms can not be allowed to continue; they must be crushed or civilization will collapse.
Civilization
Modern society with its conveniences
Returned to civilization after camping in the mountains.
Barbarism
The condition of existing barbarically.
Civilization
An organized culture encompassing many communities, often on the scale of a nation or a people; a stage or system of social, political, or technical development.
The Aztec civilization
Western civilization
Modern civilization is a product of industrialization and globalization.
Barbarism
A word hybridizing Ancient Greek and Latin or other heterogeneous roots.
Civilization
(uncountable) Human society, particularly civil society.
A hermit doesn't much care for civilization.
I'm glad to be back in civilization after a day with that rowdy family.
Barbarism
An error in language use within a single word, such as a mispronunciation.
Civilization
The act or process of civilizing or becoming civilized.
The teacher's civilization of the child was no easy task.
Barbarism
An uncivilized state or condition; rudeness of manners; ignorance of arts, learning, and literature; barbarousness.
Civilization
The state or quality of being civilized.
He was a man of great civilization.
Barbarism
A barbarous, cruel, or brutal action; an outrage.
A heinous barbarism . . . against the honor of marriage.
Civilization
(obsolete) The act of rendering a criminal process civil.
Barbarism
An offense against purity of style or language; any form of speech contrary to the pure idioms of a particular language. See Solecism.
The Greeks were the first that branded a foreign term in any of their writers with the odious name of barbarism.
Civilization
Collectively, those people of the world considered to have a high standard of behavior and / or a high level of development. Commonly subjectively used by people of one society to exclusively refer to their society, or their elite sub-group, or a few associated societies, implying all others, in time or geography or status, as something less than civilised, as savages or barbarians. cf refinement, elitism, civilised society, the Civilised World
Barbarism
A brutal barbarous savage act
Civilization
The act of civilizing, or the state of being civilized; national culture; refinement.
Our manners, our civilization, and all the good things connected with manners, and with civilization, have, in this European world of ours, depended for ages upon two principles - . . . the spirit of a gentleman, and spirit of religion.
Civilization
Rendering a criminal process civil.
Civilization
A society in an advanced state of social development (e.g., with complex legal and political and religious organizations);
The people slowly progressed from barbarism to civilization
Civilization
The social process whereby societies achieve civilization
Civilization
A particular society at a particular time and place;
Early Mayan civilization
Civilization
The quality of excellence in thought and manners and taste;
A man of intellectual refinement
He is remembered for his generosity and civilization
Common Curiosities
How do civilizations impact human rights?
Civilizations often establish systems of law and governance that aim to protect human rights, although the implementation and effectiveness can vary.
Can civilizations exhibit barbarism?
Yes, even advanced civilizations can engage in acts considered barbaric, such as during wars or in colonial contexts.
Is barbarism always negative?
While typically viewed negatively, some philosophies and literatures romanticize barbarism as a state of freedom from the constraints of civilization.
How is barbarism different from civilization?
Barbarism refers to societies or behaviors that are seen as uncivilized, often marked by cruelty or primitive conditions, contrasting with the advanced state of civilization.
What defines a civilization?
A civilization is defined by its structured government, complex societal norms, advancements in technology, and cultural achievements.
Are there any civilizations that were misunderstood as barbaric?
Historically, many societies have been mislabeled as barbaric by other civilizations due to differences in culture or technology rather than actual barbarism.
How do ethical standards differ between civilizations and barbarism?
Civilizations are expected to uphold higher ethical standards, including laws and moral guidelines, whereas barbarism is often associated with the absence or violation of these standards.
What role does technology play in defining a civilization?
Technology is a key factor in the advancement and complexity of civilizations, contributing to their economic, social, and cultural development.
Can the transition from barbarism to civilization be observed historically?
Yes, historical records and archaeological findings often show transitions from simpler, less structured societies to more complex civilizations.
What is the significance of barbarism in historical narratives?
Barbarism is often used in historical narratives to highlight conflicts between different cultural or ethical standards.
How is barbarism portrayed in popular media?
In media, barbarism is frequently portrayed through depictions of savage behavior or as a critique of the perceived loss of humanity in modern society.
What challenges do civilizations face?
Civilizations face various challenges such as maintaining social order, managing technological impacts, and addressing ethical dilemmas.
How do definitions of civilization and barbarism affect intercultural relations?
These definitions can impact intercultural relations by influencing perceptions and behaviors towards different societies, often leading to prejudice or conflict.
What are common misconceptions about barbarism?
Common misconceptions include the idea that all non-urban or non-agricultural societies are barbaric, ignoring their unique cultural complexities.
How have perceptions of barbarism changed over time?
Perceptions of barbarism have evolved, with increasing recognition of its subjective use and greater appreciation for diverse cultural expressions and histories.
Share Your Discovery
Previous Comparison
Nativism vs. EmpiricismNext Comparison
Macbeth vs. BanquoAuthor Spotlight
Written by
Tayyaba RehmanTayyaba Rehman is a distinguished writer, currently serving as a primary contributor to askdifference.com. As a researcher in semantics and etymology, Tayyaba's passion for the complexity of languages and their distinctions has found a perfect home on the platform. Tayyaba delves into the intricacies of language, distinguishing between commonly confused words and phrases, thereby providing clarity for readers worldwide.
Co-written by
Urooj ArifUrooj is a skilled content writer at Ask Difference, known for her exceptional ability to simplify complex topics into engaging and informative content. With a passion for research and a flair for clear, concise writing, she consistently delivers articles that resonate with our diverse audience.