Gramophone vs. Phonograph — What's the Difference?
By Maham Liaqat & Fiza Rafique — Updated on March 18, 2024
A gramophone reads records with a stylus, using disc-shaped media, while a phonograph, an older invention by Edison, uses a needle to play sound from cylindrical records.
Difference Between Gramophone and Phonograph
Table of Contents
ADVERTISEMENT
Key Differences
A gramophone, introduced by Emile Berliner, uses a flat, disc-shaped record. This design allowed for easier mass production and storage of recordings. On the other hand, the phonograph, invented by Thomas Edison, used a cylinder to record and reproduce sound. The cylindrical design was innovative but proved less practical for commercial production and distribution.
The sound reproduction technology of the gramophone involves a stylus following grooves in a rotating disc. This method significantly improved sound quality and volume. Whereas the phonograph's sound was reproduced by a needle running along the grooves of a rotating cylinder, resulting in lower sound quality compared to later disc systems.
Gramophones became popular for home entertainment, leading to the widespread production of disc records. This format was easier for users to handle and store, contributing to the gramophone's success. The phonograph, while pioneering, faced limitations in sound capacity and was gradually overshadowed by disc-based systems.
The development of the gramophone marked a shift towards the modern record industry, facilitating the production of recorded music on a large scale. The phonograph, despite its initial success, became more of a novelty and was eventually replaced by more efficient disc recording and playback systems.
Gramophones and phonographs both played crucial roles in the history of sound recording. However, the gramophone's use of discs laid the groundwork for the future of music distribution, making it the predecessor to modern turntables and record players.
ADVERTISEMENT
Comparison Chart
Invention Year
Late 1880s by Emile Berliner
1877 by Thomas Edison
Media Shape
Disc
Cylinder
Sound Quality
Higher due to improved technology
Lower due to earlier technology
Mass Production
Easier, leading to widespread use
More difficult, limiting distribution
Legacy
Led to modern record players and turntables
Pioneered sound recording technology
Compare with Definitions
Gramophone
An early form of a record player for disc-shaped records.
My grandparents gifted me an antique gramophone, a treasure of auditory history.
Phonograph
An early device invented by Edison to record and reproduce sound on a cylinder.
The phonograph in the exhibit demonstrated the beginnings of recorded sound.
Gramophone
An instrument of audio history, symbolizing the evolution of music playback.
The gramophone stood as an icon of technological advancement in sound reproduction.
Phonograph
A machine that captures sound waves on tin foil wrapped around a cylinder.
Innovators used the phonograph to explore the potentials of sound recording.
Gramophone
A mechanical device for playing music recorded on discs.
The gramophone's rich, warm sound brought the past musical eras to life.
Phonograph
A cylindrical record player.
The museum's phonograph had a collection of cylinder recordings from the late 19th century.
Gramophone
A sound-reproducing machine using discs.
The museum displayed a gramophone, showcasing early 20th-century entertainment.
Phonograph
A precursor to modern audio devices, using mechanical reproduction.
The phonograph's historical significance in audio development is unparalleled.
Gramophone
A device for playing records through a stylus following grooves on a disc.
The gramophone in the corner played jazz classics, filling the room with music.
Phonograph
Thomas Edison’s invention for sound recording and playback.
The phonograph marked a monumental step in the journey of sound technology.
Gramophone
A record player; a phonograph.
Phonograph
A phonograph, in its later forms also called a gramophone (as a trademark since 1887, as a generic name in the UK since 1910) or since the 1940s called a record player, is a device for the mechanical recording and reproduction of sound. The sound vibration waveforms are recorded as corresponding physical deviations of a spiral groove engraved, etched, incised, or impressed into the surface of a rotating cylinder or disc, called a "record".
Gramophone
A record player.
Phonograph
A machine that reproduces sound by means of a stylus in contact with a grooved rotating disk.
Gramophone
An instrument for recording, preserving, and reproducing sounds, the record being a tracing of a phonautograph etched in some solid material. Reproduction is accomplished by means of a system attached to an elastic diaphragm. This older term is almost completely replaced for modern devices by the word phonograph (or hi-fi), and technological changes have made the term sound antiquated, and it is usually used to refer to older non-electronic versions of the phonograph.
Phonograph
A device that captures sound waves onto an engraved archive; a lathe.
Gramophone
An antique record player; the sound of the vibrating needle is amplified acoustically
Phonograph
A device that records or plays sound from cylinder records.
Phonograph
A record player.
Phonograph
(dated) A character or symbol used to represent a sound, especially one used in phonography.
Phonograph
To record for playback by phonograph.
Phonograph
To transcribe into phonographic symbols.
Phonograph
A character or symbol used to represent a sound, esp. one used in phonography.
Phonograph
An instrument for the mechanical registration and reproduction of audible sounds, as articulate speech, etc. It consists of a rotating cylinder or disk covered with some material easily indented, as tinfoil, wax, paraffin, etc., above which is a thin plate carrying a stylus. As the plate vibrates under the influence of a sound, the stylus makes minute indentations or undulations in the soft material, and these, when the cylinder or disk is again turned, set the plate in vibration, and reproduce the sound.
Phonograph
An instrument for reproducing sounds, especially music, previously recorded on a plastic cylinder or disk as a pattern of bumps or wiggles in a groove. A needle (stylus) held in the groove is made to vibrate by motion (rotation) of the recording, and the vibrations caused by the bumps and wiggles are transmitted directly to a membrane, or first to an electronic amplifier circuit, thereby reproducing with greater or less fidelity the original sounds. A phonograph which is equipped with electronics enabling the playback of sound with high fidelity to the original is often called a hi-fi.
Phonograph
Machine in which rotating records cause a stylus to vibrate and the vibrations are amplified acoustically or electronically
Common Curiosities
Can phonograph cylinders be played on a gramophone?
No, phonograph cylinders cannot be played on a gramophone due to different media formats.
Who invented the gramophone?
Emile Berliner invented the gramophone in the late 1880s.
Are gramophones still in use today?
While not commonly used, gramophones are cherished as collectibles and sometimes used by enthusiasts for their unique sound quality.
Who invented the phonograph, and when?
Thomas Edison invented the phonograph in 1877.
Can modern music be played on a gramophone?
Modern music can be pressed onto disc records compatible with gramophones, though this is rare.
How did the phonograph impact society?
The phonograph revolutionized entertainment, education, and communication by making recorded sound accessible to the masses.
What is the main difference between a gramophone and a phonograph?
The main difference lies in their media format; gramophones use disc-shaped records, whereas phonographs use cylindrical records.
Did Edison invent the gramophone?
No, Edison invented the phonograph; Emile Berliner invented the gramophone.
Why did the disc format of the gramophone become more popular than the cylinder?
The disc format was easier to produce, store, and offered better sound quality, making it more popular.
How did gramophones contribute to the music industry?
Gramophones played a key role in the development of the music industry by facilitating mass production and distribution of recorded music.
Did the gramophone improve sound quality compared to the phonograph?
Yes, the gramophone generally offered better sound quality due to advancements in technology and design.
Is the phonograph considered the first device to record and play back sound?
Yes, the phonograph is considered the first device capable of recording and playing back sound.
How are gramophones and phonographs preserved today?
They are preserved through careful maintenance, often in climate-controlled environments, and are valued as historical artifacts.
Are there any phonographs still in working condition?
Yes, many phonographs are preserved in working condition, often featured in museums or private collections.
What kind of music was originally played on phonographs?
Originally, phonographs played a variety of music, speeches, and other audio performances recorded on cylinders.
Share Your Discovery
Previous Comparison
Scope vs. ObjectiveNext Comparison
Expect vs. HopeAuthor Spotlight
Written by
Maham LiaqatCo-written by
Fiza RafiqueFiza Rafique is a skilled content writer at AskDifference.com, where she meticulously refines and enhances written pieces. Drawing from her vast editorial expertise, Fiza ensures clarity, accuracy, and precision in every article. Passionate about language, she continually seeks to elevate the quality of content for readers worldwide.