Guild vs. Union — What's the Difference?
By Fiza Rafique & Urooj Arif — Updated on March 28, 2024
A guild is a medieval association of craftsmen or merchants, often with considerable power, while a union is an organization of workers formed to protect and advance their rights and interests.
Difference Between Guild and Union
Table of Contents
ADVERTISEMENT
Key Differences
Guilds originated in the medieval period as associations of artisans or merchants with similar interests, aiming to protect their economic interests and maintain standards within their trade. On the other hand, unions are organizations that represent the collective interests of workers, focusing on labor rights, working conditions, wages, and benefits in various industries beyond just craftsmanship or trade.
Guilds were characterized by a system of apprenticeship and mastery, where young people would learn a trade under the guidance of a master craftsman, eventually aspiring to become masters themselves. Whereas, unions typically do not offer formal training programs but instead advocate for fair labor practices, including the right to training and professional development opportunities.
The influence of guilds was often localized to specific towns or cities, where they could exert significant control over commerce, trade practices, and even local politics. Unions, however, may operate on a local, national, or international level, advocating for workers' rights across industries and borders, influencing national labor policies and global labor standards.
Membership in a guild was based on one's profession and mastery of a specific craft or trade, often requiring the production of a "masterpiece" to gain full membership. On the other hand, union membership is based on one's employment in a certain industry or company, regardless of the specific nature of the work or level of expertise.
Guilds played a significant role in the economic and social structure of medieval Europe, setting standards for quality, regulating prices, and even providing social services to their members. Unions, while also concerned with economic and social issues, primarily focus on negotiating labor contracts, protecting workers from unfai
ADVERTISEMENT
Comparison Chart
Origin
Medieval period
Industrial Revolution onwards
Purpose
Protect economic interests, maintain trade standards
Protect workers' rights, improve labor conditions
Membership Basis
Profession and mastery of craft
Employment in a specific industry or company
Level of Operation
Localized to towns or cities
Local, national, international
Functions
Apprenticeship training, economic control, social services
Advocacy for fair labor practices, wage negotiation, policy influence
Compare with Definitions
Guild
A medieval association of craftsmen or merchants.
The local guild ensured that all products met high-quality standards.
Union
An organization of workers advocating for rights.
The union called a strike to demand higher wages.
Guild
A body governing trade practices.
The guild set the prices for bread and ale in the town.
Union
A group uniting workers across various industries.
The union represents both factory workers and office staff.
Guild
A group offering apprenticeship and mastery paths.
He joined the guild as an apprentice and became a master after seven years.
Union
A body negotiating labor conditions and benefits.
The union secured a better health insurance plan for its members.
Guild
An organization promoting members' economic interests.
The guild negotiated with the city for trading rights.
Union
An entity working on local to international levels.
The union lobbied for labor law reforms at the national level.
Guild
A community providing social and economic support to members.
The guild offered financial aid to the families of deceased members.
Union
An advocate for fair labor practices and policies.
The union pushed for legislation to improve workplace safety.
Guild
A guild is an association of artisans and merchants who oversee the practice of their craft/trade in a particular area. The earliest types of guild formed as organizations of tradesmen, belonging to: a professional association, a trade union, a cartel, and/or a secret society.
Union
The act of uniting or the state of being united.
Guild
A medieval association of craftsmen or merchants, often having considerable power.
Union
A combination so formed, especially an alliance or confederation of people, parties, or political entities for mutual interest or benefit.
Guild
An association of persons of the same trade or pursuits, formed to protect mutual interests and maintain standards.
Union
(Mathematics) A set, every member of which is an element of one or another of two or more given sets.
Guild
A similar association, as of merchants or artisans, in medieval times.
Union
Agreement or harmony resulting from the uniting of individuals; concord.
Guild
(Ecology) A group of species in a community that use similar environmental resources in a similar way, such as a group of songbirds that all glean insects from leaves.
Union
The state of matrimony; marriage
"The element that was to make possible such a union was trust in each other's love" (Kate Chopin).
Guild
A group or association mainly of tradespeople made up of merchants, craftspeople, or artisans for mutual aid, particularly in the Middle Ages.
Union
A combination of parishes for joint administration of relief for the poor in Great Britain.
Guild
A corporation.
Union
A workhouse maintained by such a union.
Guild
(ecology) A group of diverse species that share common characteristics or habits.
Union
A labor union.
Guild
(video games) An organized group of players who regularly play together in a multiplayer game.
Union
A coupling device for connecting parts, such as pipes or rods.
Guild
An association of men belonging to the same class, or engaged in kindred pursuits, formed for mutual aid and protection; a business fraternity or corporation; as, the Stationers' Guild; the Ironmongers' Guild. They were originally licensed by the government, and endowed with special privileges and authority.
Union
A device on a flag or ensign, occupying the upper inner corner or the entire field, that signifies the union of two or more sovereignties.
Guild
A guildhall.
Union
An organization at a college or university that provides facilities for recreation; a student union.
Guild
A religious association or society, organized for charitable purposes or for assistance in parish work.
Union
A building housing such facilities.
Guild
A formal association of people with similar interests;
He joined a golf club
They formed a small lunch society
Men from the fraternal order will staff the soup kitchen today
Union
Union The United States of America regarded as a national unit, especially during the Civil War.
Union
Union Of, relating to, or loyal to the United States of America during the Civil War
A Union soldier.
Union
Of or relating to a labor union or labor union organizing
The union movement.
Union negotiations.
Union
(countable) The act of uniting or joining two or more things into one.
Union
(countable) The state of being united or joined; a state of unity or harmony.
Union
(countable) That which is united, or made one; something formed by a combination or coalition of parts or members; a confederation; a consolidated body; a league.
Union
(countable) A trade union; a workers' union.
Union
(countable) An association of students at a university for social and/or political purposes; also in some cases a debating body.
Union
(countable) A joint or other connection uniting parts of machinery, such as pipes.
Union
The set containing all of the elements of two or more sets.
Union
(countable) The act or state of marriage.
Union
A data structure that can store any of various types of item, but only one at a time.
Union
A large, high-quality pearl.
Union
(historical) An affiliation of several parishes for joint support and management of their poor; also the jointly-owned workhouse.
Union
To combine sets using the union operation.
Union
Belonging to, represented by, or otherwise pertaining to a labour union.
Actors have to be union to get work here.
Union
The act of uniting or joining two or more things into one, or the state of being united or joined; junction; coalition; combination.
Union
Agreement and conjunction of mind, spirit, will, affections, or the like; harmony; concord.
Union
That which is united, or made one; something formed by a combination or coalition of parts or members; a confederation; a consolidated body; a league; as, the weavers have formed a union; trades unions have become very numerous; the United States of America are often called the Union.
Union
A textile fabric composed of two or more materials, as cotton, silk, wool, etc., woven together.
Union
A large, fine pearl.
If they [pearls] be white, great, round, smooth, and weighty . . . our dainties and delicates here at Rome . . . call them unions, as a man would say "singular," and by themselves alone.
In the cup an union shall he throw,Richer than that which four successive kingsIn Denmark's crown have worn.
Union
A device emblematic of union, used on a national flag or ensign, sometimes, as in the military standard of Great Britain, covering the whole field; sometimes, as in the flag of the United States, and the English naval and marine flag, occupying the upper inner corner, the rest of the flag being called the fly. Also, a flag having such a device; especially, the flag of Great Britain.
Union
A joint or other connection uniting parts of machinery, or the like, as the elastic pipe of a tender connecting it with the feed pipe of a locomotive engine; especially, a pipe fitting for connecting pipes, or pipes and fittings, in such a way as to facilitate disconnection.
Union
A cask suspended on trunnions, in which fermentation is carried on.
One kingdom, joy, and union without end.
[Man] is to . . . begetLike of his like, his image multiplied.In unity defective; which requiresCollateral love, and dearest amity.
Union
An organization of employees formed to bargain with the employer;
You have to join the union in order to get a job
Union
The United States (especially the northern states during the American Civil War);
He has visited every state in the Union
Lee hoped to detach Maryland from the Union
The North's superior resources turned the scale
Union
The act of pairing a male and female for reproductive purposes;
The casual couplings of adolescents
The mating of some species occurs only in the spring
Union
The state of being joined or united or linked;
There is strength in union
Union
The state of being a married couple voluntarily joined for life (or until divorce);
A long and happy marriage
God bless this union
Union
Healing process involving the growing together of the edges of a wound or the growing together of broken bones
Union
A political unit formed from previously independent people or organizations;
The Soviet Union
Union
A set containing all and only the members of two or more given sets;
Let C be the union of the sets A and B
Union
The occurrence of a uniting of separate parts;
Lightning produced an unusual union of the metals
Union
A device on a national flag emblematic of the union of two or more sovereignties (typically in the upper inner corner)
Union
The act of making or becoming a single unit;
The union of opposing factions
He looked forward to the unification of his family for the holidays
Union
Being of or having to do with the northern United States and those loyal to the Union during the Civil War;
Union soldiers
Federal forces
A Federal infantryman
Union
Of trade unions;
The union movement
Union negotiations
A union-shop clause in the contract
Common Curiosities
What is a union?
A union is an organization formed by workers to advocate for their rights, including fair wages, safe working conditions, and benefits.
What is the main goal of a union?
The main goal of a union is to protect and advance workers' rights and interests through collective bargaining and advocacy.
What is a guild?
A guild is a medieval association of people in the same trade or craft, aiming to protect their economic interests and uphold standards.
How did guilds support their members?
Guilds supported members through apprenticeship training, setting trade standards, and providing economic and social support.
Are guilds still active today?
While traditional guilds are rare, some professions maintain guild-like organizations focusing on standards, networking, and advocacy.
Can guilds be considered early forms of unions?
In some ways, yes, as guilds also aimed to protect members' interests and regulate trades, though their scope and functions differed from modern unions.
How did one become a member of a guild?
Membership typically involved completing an apprenticeship and demonstrating mastery of the craft, sometimes by producing a masterpiece.
Can anyone join a guild?
Historically, joining a guild required proving one's skill in a craft or trade, often through an apprenticeship and the creation of a masterpiece.
What rights do unions fight for?
Unions fight for rights like fair pay, safe working conditions, reasonable hours, benefits, and protection from unjust termination.
How do unions and guilds differ in their approach to training?
Guilds directly provided apprenticeship and training within their trade, whereas unions advocate for training opportunities but typically do not provide training themselves.
Who can join a union?
Generally, anyone employed in a particular industry or company represented by the union can join, regardless of their specific job or skill level.
Did guilds have any political power?
Yes, in medieval towns and cities, guilds often had significant political power, influencing local governance and trade policies.
How do unions influence labor laws?
Unions influence labor laws by lobbying politicians, participating in policy discussions, and advocating for legislation that benefits workers.
What are the benefits of union membership?
Benefits include collective bargaining power, legal representation, access to negotiated benefits, and support in labor disputes.
What happens during a union strike?
During a strike, union members stop working to protest against their employers, demanding improvements in labor conditions or pay.
Share Your Discovery
Previous Comparison
Ovary vs. Ovule
Next Comparison
Mailman vs. PostmanAuthor Spotlight
Written by
Fiza RafiqueFiza Rafique is a skilled content writer at AskDifference.com, where she meticulously refines and enhances written pieces. Drawing from her vast editorial expertise, Fiza ensures clarity, accuracy, and precision in every article. Passionate about language, she continually seeks to elevate the quality of content for readers worldwide.
Co-written by
Urooj ArifUrooj is a skilled content writer at Ask Difference, known for her exceptional ability to simplify complex topics into engaging and informative content. With a passion for research and a flair for clear, concise writing, she consistently delivers articles that resonate with our diverse audience.
