Heaven vs. Purgatory — What's the Difference?
By Maham Liaqat & Urooj Arif — Updated on April 23, 2024
Heaven is often depicted as a blissful, eternal dwelling place for righteous after death, according to many religious beliefs, while Purgatory is considered a temporary state of purification for souls who are destined for Heaven but are not free from sin.
Difference Between Heaven and Purgatory
Table of Contents
ADVERTISEMENT
Key Differences
Heaven is typically viewed as the ultimate reward, a place of eternal peace and divine presence where souls experience everlasting joy and fulfillment after death. In contrast, Purgatory is envisioned as a transitional state where souls undergo purification to achieve the holiness necessary to enter Heaven, primarily in Catholic doctrine.
While Heaven is described as a perfect and permanent abode without suffering or sin, Purgatory is characterized by a process of cleansing and preparation, where souls may experience some form of suffering as they are purified of their sins. This temporary suffering is seen as a necessary step before reaching the sanctity required for Heaven.
The concept of Heaven is found in many world religions, each with its own interpretations but generally agreeing on its nature as a state of sublime happiness. Purgatory, however, is specifically a concept within Catholicism and some other Christian denominations, not universally recognized by all branches of Christianity or other faiths.
Believers see entering Heaven as the goal of the faithful life, where one is reunited with loved ones and the divine, in contrast to Purgatory, which serves as a remedial state only for those who die in God’s grace but still need to be purified from venial sins or the temporal punishments due to forgiven sins.
The idea of Purgatory emphasizes God’s mercy, allowing those who have died in friendship with God but imperfectly purified to undergo the necessary transformation to enter Heaven. Heaven, on the other hand, is the realization of a complete and perfect union with the divine, marking the fulfillment of the soul’s journey.
ADVERTISEMENT
Comparison Chart
Nature
Eternal and perfect dwelling.
Temporary state for purification.
Purpose
Reward and fulfillment of the righteous.
Preparation and cleansing of souls.
Suffering
Absence of pain or sorrow.
Presence of purifying suffering.
Duration
Eternal.
Temporary, duration varies per soul.
Theological Basis
Universal across many religions.
Primarily in Catholic and some Christian denominations.
Compare with Definitions
Heaven
A place of perfect harmony and bliss.
The artist painted his vision of Heaven filled with light and beauty.
Purgatory
The process of suffering for the purging of sins.
Medieval literature often depicted Purgatory with vivid imagery of fire and redemption.
Heaven
The ultimate state of eternal happiness with God.
They believed their grandmother was at peace in Heaven.
Purgatory
A state of purification for certain souls.
The doctrine teaches that Purgatory cleanses the soul before it enters Heaven.
Heaven
Symbolic of utmost happiness and divine presence.
The serene landscape was like Heaven on earth.
Purgatory
A concept in Catholic theology for the dead undergoing purification.
The church held masses to aid those in Purgatory.
Heaven
The final reward for the righteous after life on earth.
His faith promised him a place in Heaven.
Purgatory
Believed to be a place where forgiven sins are purified.
According to the church, Purgatory is a merciful gift allowing purification.
Heaven
A spiritual realm of the afterlife in various religions.
In many cultures, Heaven is depicted as above the skies.
Purgatory
A temporary place where souls are made fit for Heaven.
Her prayers were offered for the souls in Purgatory.
Heaven
Heaven or the heavens, is a common religious cosmological or transcendent supernatural place where beings such as gods, angels, spirits, saints, or venerated ancestors are said to originate, be enthroned, or reside. According to the beliefs of some religions, heavenly beings can descend to Earth or incarnate and earthly beings can ascend to Heaven in the afterlife or, in exceptional cases, enter Heaven alive.
Purgatory
(in Catholic doctrine) a place or state of suffering inhabited by the souls of sinners who are expiating their sins before going to heaven
The punishment of souls in purgatory
All her sins were forgiven and she would not need to go to Purgatory
Heaven
Often heavens The sky or universe as seen from the earth; the firmament.
Purgatory
Having the quality of cleansing or purifying
Infernal punishments are purgatory and medicinal
Heaven
Often Heaven The abode of God, the angels, and the souls of those who are granted salvation.
Purgatory
Roman Catholic Church A state in which the souls of those who have died in grace must expiate their sins.
Heaven
An eternal state of communion with God; everlasting bliss.
Purgatory
A place or condition of suffering, expiation, or remorse
A purgatory of drug abuse.
Heaven
Any of the places in or beyond the sky conceived of as domains of divine beings in various religions.
Purgatory
Tending to cleanse or purge.
Heaven
Heaven God
Heaven help you!.
Purgatory
(Christianity) Purgatory
Heaven
Heavens Used in various phrases to express surprise
Good heavens!.
Purgatory
Any situation where suffering is endured, particularly as part of a process of redemption.
Heaven
Often heavens The celestial powers; the gods
The heavens favored the young prince.
Purgatory
Tending to cleanse; expiatory.
Heaven
A condition or place of great happiness, delight, or pleasure
The lake was heaven.
Purgatory
Tending to cleanse; cleansing; expiatory.
Heaven
The sky, specifically:
Purgatory
A temporary condition of torment or suffering;
A purgatory of drug abuse
Heaven
The distant sky in which the sun, moon, and stars appear or move; the firmament; the celestial spheres.
Purgatory
(theology) in Roman Catholic theology the place where those who have died in a state of grace undergo limited torment to expiate their sins
Heaven
(obsolete) The near sky in which weather, flying animals, etc. appear; (obsolete) the atmosphere; the climate.
Heaven
(obsolete) A model displaying the movement of the celestial bodies, an orrery.
Heaven
(religion) The abode of God or the gods, traditionally conceived as beyond the sky; especially:
Heaven
The abode of God and of the angels and saints in His presence.
Heaven
The abode of the Abrahamic God; similar abodes of the gods in other religions and traditions, such as Mount Olympus.
Heaven
Providence, the will of God or the council of the gods; fate.
Heaven
(religion) The afterlife of the blessed dead, traditionally conceived as opposed to an afterlife of the wicked and unjust (compare hell); specifically:
Heaven
The afterlife of the blessed dead in other religions and traditions, such as the Pure Land or Elysium.
Heaven
(by extension) Any paradise; any blissful place or experience.
Heaven
(by extension) A state of bliss; a peaceful ecstasy.
Heaven
Similarly blissful afterlives, places, or states for particular people, animals, or objects.
Heaven
(obsolete) To transport to the abode of God, the gods, or the blessed.
Heaven
(obsolete) To beatify, enchant, or please greatly.
Heaven
(obsolete) To beautify, to make into a paradise.
Heaven
The expanse of space surrounding the earth; esp., that which seems to be over the earth like a great arch or dome; the firmament; the sky; the place where the sun, moon, and stars appear; - often used in the plural in this sense.
I never saw the heavens so dim by day.
When my eyes shall be turned to behold for the last time the sun in heaven.
Heaven
The sovereign of heaven; God; also, the assembly of the blessed, collectively; - used variously in this sense, as in No. 2.; as, heaven helps those who help themselves.
Her prayers, whom Heaven delights to hear.
The willAnd high permission of all-ruling Heaven.
Heaven
Any place of supreme happiness or great comfort; perfect felicity; bliss; a sublime or exalted condition; as, a heaven of delight.
O bed! bed! delicious bed!That heaven upon earth to the weary head!
Heaven
To place in happiness or bliss, as if in heaven; to beatify.
We are happy as the bird whose nestIs heavened in the hush of purple hills.
Heaven
Any place of complete bliss and delight and peace
Heaven
The abode of God and the angels
Common Curiosities
How does Purgatory differ from Heaven in its purpose?
Purgatory is a temporary state meant for the purification of souls, whereas Heaven is a permanent state of bliss.
How can one avoid Purgatory according to Catholic belief?
Through a life of penance, receiving sacraments, and obtaining indulgences to reduce purification time.
What is the purpose of Heaven?
Heaven serves as the eternal home for souls who have achieved divine grace and moral perfection.
What happens to souls in Heaven?
Souls in Heaven enjoy eternal peace, joy, and the presence of God.
Can people in Heaven communicate with those in Purgatory?
Most religious beliefs that accept these concepts generally do not support such communication as doctrinal.
How is Purgatory depicted in art and literature?
It is often depicted as a place of fire and purification, seen in works like Dante’s "Divine Comedy."
Is Purgatory considered a second chance for salvation?
Not exactly; it is for those already saved but who need purification to enter Heaven.
Do all religions believe in Purgatory?
No, the concept of Purgatory is specific to Catholicism and some other Christian traditions, not accepted in many other religions.
Is there a way to help souls in Purgatory?
Yes, prayers, masses, and good deeds can be offered on behalf of souls in Purgatory to ease their suffering.
What are the key differences in the experiences of souls in Heaven and Purgatory?
Souls in Heaven experience complete joy and fulfillment, while those in Purgatory undergo necessary purification.
Why is Purgatory necessary according to Catholic doctrine?
It provides a state where souls can be purified of their sins and temporal punishments before entering Heaven.
Can anyone go to Heaven directly after death?
According to many beliefs, particularly virtuous individuals may enter Heaven directly without the need for Purgatory.
What role does faith play in reaching Heaven?
Faith, along with good deeds and moral integrity, is essential in many religions for reaching Heaven.
What impact does belief in Heaven and Purgatory have on followers?
These beliefs influence moral behavior and provide comfort regarding the afterlife.
Does belief in Heaven and Purgatory affect grief?
Yes, these beliefs often help followers cope with death and loss, offering hope of eventual reunion.
Share Your Discovery
Previous Comparison
Baleful vs. BanefulNext Comparison
Collage vs. MosaicAuthor Spotlight
Written by
Maham LiaqatCo-written by
Urooj ArifUrooj is a skilled content writer at Ask Difference, known for her exceptional ability to simplify complex topics into engaging and informative content. With a passion for research and a flair for clear, concise writing, she consistently delivers articles that resonate with our diverse audience.