Italian vs. Sicilian — What's the Difference?
By Fiza Rafique & Urooj Arif — Updated on May 14, 2024
Italian is the official language of Italy with broad regional varieties, while Sicilian is a distinct language spoken primarily in Sicily, reflecting deep local heritage.
Difference Between Italian and Sicilian
Table of Contents
ADVERTISEMENT
Key Differences
Italian, standardized and based largely on the dialects of Tuscany, serves as Italy's official language and is one of the major Romance languages recognized globally. Whereas Sicilian, though part of the same Romance language family, is a regional language with its own unique set of grammar, vocabulary, and pronunciation, reflecting a rich history of various cultural influences including Arabic, Greek, and Spanish.
The Italian language has a standardized orthography and grammar used throughout Italy for educational and administrative purposes. It's also one of the official languages of the European Union. On the other hand, Sicilian remains largely a spoken language with varied dialects across different regions of Sicily, lacking a standard writing system which makes its use in formal contexts limited.
Italian is spoken by about 85 million people worldwide as a first language and is widely taught and understood in various countries. Sicilian, however, is primarily spoken in Sicily and by expatriate communities from Sicily, with speakers estimated to be around 5 million, indicating a more geographically confined use.
Cultural representation in Italian is vast, spanning centuries of literature, music, and cinema, contributing significantly to Western culture and art. Conversely, Sicilian culture, while also rich and varied, is more localized, featuring folk music, poetry, and other cultural expressions that prominently use the Sicilian language, reflecting the island's unique historical and social developments.
The status of Italian as a globally recognized language affords it considerable prestige and resources for learning and dissemination. Sicilian, while an integral part of Italy's linguistic heritage, often relies on grassroots movements for preservation and promotion, highlighting a community-driven approach to maintaining linguistic identity.
ADVERTISEMENT
Comparison Chart
Classification
Romance language
Romance language
Origin
Based on Tuscan dialects
Originates from Sicily
Standardization
Standardized orthography and grammar
No standard writing system
Geographic Spread
Spoken worldwide
Mainly spoken in Sicily
Number of Speakers
Approximately 85 million worldwide
About 5 million primarily in Sicily
Cultural Influence
Extensive, global
Rich but localized to Sicily
Usage in Education
Widely taught and used in education
Limited formal educational use
Compare with Definitions
Italian
A Romance language used officially in Italy and several other countries.
He spoke Italian fluently after studying in Rome for a year.
Sicilian
Integral to Sicilian folk music and oral poetry traditions.
Sicilian language is often used in traditional songs and folk tales passed down through generations.
Italian
Taught as a second language in many countries around the world.
Italian is a popular choice for language learners, appreciated for its beauty and cultural richness.
Sicilian
A Romance language with a rich lexicon influenced by Greek, Arabic, and Spanish.
Sicilian includes words like azzizzari from Arabic, meaning to embellish or adorn.
Italian
Features a significant literary corpus including works by Dante, Petrarch, and Boccaccio.
Italian literature is studied worldwide, with Dante's Divine Comedy being a key historical text.
Sicilian
Lacks a standardized form, leading to diverse dialects across Sicily.
The Sicilian spoken in Palermo can be quite different from that spoken in Catania.
Italian
Characterized by its use in classical music terminology and opera.
Italian terms like allegro and adagio are essential for understanding musical compositions.
Sicilian
Predominantly spoken in Sicily and among Sicilian immigrants.
Sicilian is often heard in communities of Sicilian descent in the United States and Australia.
Italian
Used officially in administration, education, and media in Italy.
Italian is the language used for all governmental proceedings in Italy.
Sicilian
Efforts to preserve the language focus on cultural and educational initiatives.
Local schools in Sicily sometimes host workshops to teach students about Sicilian language and culture.
Italian
Relating to Italy, its people, or their language.
Sicilian
Of or relating to Sicily or its people, language, or culture.
Italian
A native or inhabitant of Italy, or a person of Italian descent.
Sicilian
A native or inhabitant of Sicily.
Italian
The Romance language of Italy, descended from Latin and with roughly 60 million speakers worldwide. It is also one of the official languages of Switzerland.
Sicilian
A person of Sicilian ancestry.
Italian
Of or relating to Italy or its people, language, or culture.
Sicilian
The Romance language spoken by many Sicilians in daily life. Sicilian is sometimes considered a dialect of Italian.
Italian
A native or inhabitant of Italy.
Sicilian
Of or pertaining to Sicily or its inhabitants.
Italian
A person of Italian ancestry.
Sicilian
A native or inhabitant of Sicily.
Italian
The Romance language of the Italians and an official language of Switzerland.
Sicilian
A resident of Sicily
Italian
Of or pertaining to Italy, or to its people or language.
Sicilian
Of or relating to or characteristic of Sicily or the people of Sicily;
The Sicilian Mafia
Italian
A native or inhabitant of Italy.
Italian
The language used in Italy, or by the Italians.
Italian
A native or inhabitant of Italy
Italian
The Romance language spoken in Italy
Italian
Of or pertaining to or characteristic of Italy or its people or culture or language;
Italian cooking
Common Curiosities
What is the main difference between Italian and Sicilian?
Italian is a standardized Romance language spoken throughout Italy and beyond, while Sicilian is a regional language with its own distinct characteristics, spoken mainly in Sicily.
Why isn't Sicilian standardized like Italian?
Sicilian has evolved with varied influences and without the political or cultural movements that typically push for standardization.
What role does Italian play in international contexts?
Italian is widely used in the arts, fashion, culinary arts, and diplomacy, marking its presence in international affairs.
Can Italian speakers easily understand Sicilian?
Italian speakers may understand some Sicilian due to similarities in vocabulary and structure, but they might find it difficult without exposure to the language.
Is Sicilian just a dialect of Italian?
No, Sicilian is considered a separate language with its own grammar and vocabulary, distinct from standard Italian.
What impact does Italian have on the global cultural landscape?
Italian influences global culture through its contributions to art, music, fashion, and cuisine, making it a culturally significant language globally.
How is Sicilian preserved and promoted?
Sicilian is preserved through cultural practices, local media, and education initiatives that promote the language and culture in Sicily and among the Sicilian diaspora.
What efforts are being made to keep Sicilian alive?
Efforts include local literature publications, music, educational programs, and community activities that encourage the speaking and teaching of Sicilian.
Can learning Sicilian offer cultural benefits?
Learning Sicilian can provide deeper insights into the unique culture, history, and traditions of Sicily and its people.
What are the professional benefits of learning Italian?
Learning Italian can provide professional opportunities in Italy's diverse industries, including fashion, automotive, manufacturing, and tourism.
Is Sicilian recognized as a minority language in Italy?
Yes, Sicilian is recognized as a minority language and efforts are ongoing to protect and promote its use.
Are there resources available for learning Sicilian?
There are fewer resources compared to Italian, but various online platforms, community courses, and books are available for those interested.
What makes Italian a popular language to learn?
Italian's popularity is bolstered by its association with history, art, and culinary tradition, making it attractive to learners for both cultural and practical reasons.
How are new speakers of Sicilian being cultivated?
New speakers are cultivated through educational programs, family transmission, and cultural engagement within Sicilian communities.
What are the literary contributions of Sicilian language?
Sicilian has a rich oral tradition and contributions to Italian literature through poets like Salvatore Quasimodo, who wrote also in Sicilian.
Share Your Discovery
Previous Comparison
Companionship vs. FriendshipNext Comparison
Overdrive vs. LibbyAuthor Spotlight
Written by
Fiza RafiqueFiza Rafique is a skilled content writer at AskDifference.com, where she meticulously refines and enhances written pieces. Drawing from her vast editorial expertise, Fiza ensures clarity, accuracy, and precision in every article. Passionate about language, she continually seeks to elevate the quality of content for readers worldwide.
Co-written by
Urooj ArifUrooj is a skilled content writer at Ask Difference, known for her exceptional ability to simplify complex topics into engaging and informative content. With a passion for research and a flair for clear, concise writing, she consistently delivers articles that resonate with our diverse audience.