Kohl vs. Eyeliner — What's the Difference?
By Urooj Arif & Maham Liaqat — Updated on May 2, 2024
Kohl is a traditional eye cosmetic made from powdered minerals, often used for smudging, while eyeliner is a modern makeup product designed for precise lines.
Difference Between Kohl and Eyeliner
Table of Contents
ADVERTISEMENT
Key Differences
Kohl, traditionally made from natural ingredients like soot and other minerals, is known for its soft texture that allows easy smudging around the eye area to create a smokey look. On the other hand, eyeliner comes in various forms including pencil, gel, and liquid, and is crafted to deliver sharp, defined lines that highlight the shape of the eyes.
Kohl has been used for centuries in many cultures, primarily in the Middle East and North Africa, for both cosmetic and protective purposes, as it is believed to ward off evil eyes. Eyeliner, however, has become a staple in contemporary beauty routines worldwide, focusing more on enhancing aesthetic appeal rather than cultural symbolism.
The application of kohl typically involves lining the waterline and can be easily blended across the eyelid due to its powdery consistency. Whereas, eyeliner application is more versatile, allowing for precise application that includes tightlining, winged tips, and detailed artistic designs on the eyelid.
In terms of composition, kohl is mainly composed of natural minerals and does not usually contain preservatives or synthetic chemicals. Conversely, eyeliners can contain a variety of ingredients including waxes, silicones, and preservatives to enhance application, longevity, and color intensity.
Comparison Chart
Composition
Made from natural minerals and soot.
Can include waxes, silicones, and preservatives.
ADVERTISEMENT
Application Area
Mainly the waterline.
Waterline, lash line, and beyond.
Primary Use
Smudging for a soft, smokey effect.
Sharp lines for defined eye shapes.
Cultural Association
Middle Eastern and African traditions.
Modern, global cosmetic use.
Longevity
Tends to smudge and fade quickly.
Formulated to be long-lasting and smudge-proof.
Compare with Definitions
Kohl
Often made from natural ingredients like charcoal.
His kohl was homemade, using traditional recipes.
Eyeliner
A makeup product used to define the eyes.
She used a black eyeliner to perfect her cat-eye look.
Kohl
Has a soft consistency that easily smudges.
Her kohl smudged, giving her a more dramatic look.
Eyeliner
Available in forms such as pencil, gel, and liquid.
For his performance, he chose a waterproof gel eyeliner.
Kohl
A powdery cosmetic used to darken eyelids and as an eyeliner.
She applied kohl to achieve a mysterious, smokey eye effect.
Eyeliner
A staple in both minimalist and elaborate makeup routines.
Even for a simple look, she never forgot to apply her eyeliner.
Kohl
Rich in cultural significance in many societies.
Kohl has been a significant part of her cultural heritage for centuries.
Eyeliner
Can be used for intricate eye makeup designs.
She used her liquid eyeliner to draw fine, artistic lines above her eyelids.
Kohl
Used for both protective and cosmetic purposes.
She wore kohl not just to enhance her beauty, but also to protect her eyes from the sun.
Eyeliner
Often designed to be waterproof or smudge-proof.
Her eyeliner stayed intact throughout the rainy day.
Kohl
A cosmetic preparation, such as powdered antimony sulfide, used especially in the Middle East to darken the rims of the eyelids.
Eyeliner
Makeup used to outline the eyes.
Kohl
A dark powder (usually powdered antimony) used as eye makeup, especially in Eastern countries; stibnite.
Eyeliner
Makeup used to outline the eye, generally applied along or close to the lashline.
Kohl
To decorate one's eyes with kohl.
Eyeliner
A cosmetic powder of a dark tint, applied to the eyelid close to the base of the eyelashes to accentuate the eyes. Compare eye shadow.
Kohl
A mixture of soot and other ingredients, used by Egyptian and other Eastern women to darken the edges of the eyelids.
Eyeliner
Makeup applied to emphasize the shape of the eyes
Kohl
A cosmetic preparation used by women in Egypt and Arabia to darken the edges of their eyelids
Common Curiosities
How is eyeliner different from kohl in terms of application?
Eyeliner is used for creating precise lines and detailed designs, whereas kohl is better suited for smudging and achieving a smokey eye effect.
Is eyeliner safe to use on the waterline?
Certain eyeliners are designed to be safe for waterline use, but it's important to choose products specifically tested for this sensitive area.
What are the benefits of using kohl?
Besides its cosmetic benefits, kohl is also traditionally believed to offer protection against eye infections and sunlight.
How long does kohl last once applied?
Kohl may need to be reapplied throughout the day as it tends to smudge and fade quicker than modern eyeliners.
Can kohl be used daily?
Yes, kohl can be used daily, especially if made from natural ingredients, though it's important to ensure it's free of harmful contaminants.
Is kohl suitable for all skin types?
Yes, kohl is generally suitable for all skin types, especially because it is often made from natural ingredients. However, those with sensitive eyes should check for allergens.
What is kohl made from?
Kohl is typically made from powdered minerals such as lead sulfide and other natural ingredients.
What types of eyeliner are best for beginners?
Pencil eyeliners are often recommended for beginners due to their ease of use and control.
How can one achieve a winged eyeliner look?
To achieve a winged eyeliner look, use a liquid or gel eyeliner with a fine brush for precision and draw the wing outward from the outer corner of the eye.
Can eyeliner be used as kohl?
Some eyeliners that are creamy and soft enough can be smudged similarly to kohl for a smokey effect, though they may not blend as easily.
Share Your Discovery
Previous Comparison
Landslide vs. Mudslide
Next Comparison
Swollen vs. SwollennessAuthor Spotlight
Written by
Urooj ArifUrooj is a skilled content writer at Ask Difference, known for her exceptional ability to simplify complex topics into engaging and informative content. With a passion for research and a flair for clear, concise writing, she consistently delivers articles that resonate with our diverse audience.
Co-written by
Maham Liaqat
