Melancholic vs. Melancholy — What's the Difference?
By Fiza Rafique & Maham Liaqat — Updated on April 20, 2024
Melancholic refers to a person characterized by melancholy—deep sadness or gloom—while melancholy is the feeling or mood of pervasive sadness itself.
Difference Between Melancholic and Melancholy
Table of Contents
ADVERTISEMENT
Key Differences
Melancholic describes an individual or temperament that exhibits traits of deep sadness and pensiveness, often used in psychological and literary contexts to discuss personality types. Whereas melancholy pertains to the actual emotional state, signifying profound sadness or despondency, and is commonly used in both everyday and artistic expressions to describe an atmosphere or mood.
Individuals described as melancholic often display a consistent, long-term tendency towards sadness and reflection, suggesting a stable trait or characteristic. On the other hand, melancholy can be a temporary state, influenced by specific events, environments, or moments, reflecting a more transient nature.
Historically, melancholic was used in the context of the four temperaments theory, classifying it as a personality type prone to sadness and deep thought. Melancholy, in contrast, has been a central theme in art and literature, used to evoke a somber beauty or profound introspection.
In medical or psychological discussions, melancholic can denote a subtype of depression, characterized by severe features of melancholy such as profound sadness or hopelessness. Melancholy, however, often lacks the clinical connotations, serving more as a poetic or everyday term for feelings of sadness.
Linguistically, melancholic functions as an adjective, thus modifying nouns and describing characteristics of individuals or atmospheres. Melancholy, however, acts primarily as a noun but can also be used adjectivally, offering flexibility in usage across different contexts.
ADVERTISEMENT
Comparison Chart
Part of Speech
Adjective
Noun (primarily), Adjective
Usage
Describes people or temperaments
Describes feelings or atmospheres
Duration
Often long-term or inherent in nature
Can be temporary or situational
Context
Psychological, medical, literary
Everyday language, artistic
Connotation
Often clinical or analytical
Emotional, poetic
Compare with Definitions
Melancholic
Pertaining to deep sadness or gloom.
The artist’s melancholic expression revealed his inner turmoil.
Melancholy
Serving as an adjective to describe gloomy situations.
The poet wrote several melancholy poems.
Melancholic
Reflective of a gloomy character.
His melancholic demeanor made him a perfect fit for the role of Hamlet.
Melancholy
A deep, pensive, and long-lasting sadness.
There was a touch of melancholy in her smile.
Melancholic
Inclined to introspection and pensive sadness.
She had a melancholic temperament, often lost in her thoughts.
Melancholy
Used to describe somber or sad atmospheres.
The melody carried a melancholy tone.
Melancholic
Associated with a depressive subtype.
Melancholic depression is characterized by a loss of pleasure in all activities.
Melancholy
Relating to the emotional aspect of sadness.
Melancholy swept over her as she walked through her old neighborhood.
Melancholic
Stemming from an ancient theory of bodily humors.
As a melancholic, he was believed to have an excess of black bile.
Melancholy
A feeling of thoughtful sadness.
The rainy weather filled him with melancholy.
Melancholic
Feeling or expressing pensive sadness
His work often has a wistful or melancholic mood
A haunting, melancholic melody
Melancholy
A feeling of pensive sadness, typically with no obvious cause
He had an ability to convey a sense of deep melancholy and yearning through much of his work
An air of melancholy surrounded him
At the centre of his music lies a profound melancholy and nostalgia
Melancholic
Affected with or subject to melancholy.
Melancholy
Having a feeling of melancholy; sad and pensive
She felt a little melancholy
A dark, melancholy young man with deep-set eyes
Melancholic
Of or relating to melancholia.
Melancholy
Sadness or depression of the spirits; gloom.
Melancholic
Filled with or affected by melancholy—great sadness or depression, especially of a thoughtful or introspective nature.
Melancholy
Pensive reflection or contemplation.
Melancholic
(dated) Pertaining to black bile (melancholy).
Melancholy
Black bile.
Melancholic
(classical temperament) Pertaining to the melancholic temperament or its associated personality traits.
Melancholy
An emotional state characterized by sullenness and outbreaks of violent anger, believed to arise from an excess of black bile.
Melancholic
A person who is habitually melancholy.
Melancholy
Feeling, showing, or expressing depression of the spirits; sad or dejected.
Melancholic
Given to melancholy; depressed; melancholy; dejected; unhappy.
Just as the melancholic eyeSees fleets and armies in the sky.
Melancholy
Causing or tending to cause sadness or gloom
A letter with some melancholy news.
Melancholic
One affected with a gloomy state of mind.
Melancholy
Pensive; thoughtful.
Melancholic
A gloomy state of mind; melancholy.
Melancholy
(historical) Black bile, formerly thought to be one of the four "cardinal humours" of animal bodies.
Melancholic
Someone subject to melancholia
Melancholy
Great sadness or depression, especially of a thoughtful or introspective nature.
Melancholic
Characterized by or causing or expressing sadness;
Growing more melancholy every hour
Her melancholic smile
We acquainted him with the melancholy truth
Melancholy
(literary) Affected with great sadness or depression.
Melancholy people don't talk much.
Melancholy
Depression of spirits; a gloomy state continuing a considerable time; deep dejection; gloominess.
Melancholy
Great and continued depression of spirits, amounting to mental unsoundness; melancholia.
Melancholy
Pensive maditation; serious thoughtfulness.
Melancholy
Ill nature.
Melancholy
Depressed in spirits; dejected; gloomy dismal.
Melancholy
Producing great evil and grief; causing dejection; calamitous; afflictive; as, a melancholy event.
Melancholy
Somewhat deranged in mind; having the jugment impaired.
Melancholy
Favorable to meditation; somber.
A pretty, melancholy seat, well wooded and watered.
Melancholy
A feeling of thoughtful sadness
Melancholy
A constitutional tendency to be gloomy and depressed
Melancholy
A humor that was once believed to be secreted by the kidneys or spleen and to cause sadness and melancholy
Melancholy
Characterized by or causing or expressing sadness;
Growing more melancholy every hour
Her melancholic smile
We acquainted him with the melancholy truth
Common Curiosities
Are there any famous literary works that explore melancholy or melancholic themes?
Yes, many works such as John Keats' "Ode on Melancholy" and Shakespeare’s play "Hamlet" explore themes of melancholy and feature melancholic characters.
Can animals exhibit melancholic traits?
While animals can show signs of sadness, the term melancholic is specifically used to describe human emotions and temperaments, rooted in psychological and cultural contexts that are not applicable to animals.
How is melancholic depression different from other types of depression?
Melancholic depression is characterized by a profound lack of response to pleasurable activities, excessive guilt, and features that are more severe than other types of depression.
Is melancholy always negative?
Not necessarily; in some cultural and artistic contexts, melancholy is appreciated for its depth and the introspective insight it can inspire, despite its general association with sadness.
Are there any specific genres of music that are associated with melancholy?
Yes, genres like blues, some forms of jazz, and classical music often explore themes of melancholy in their compositions.
Is melancholic a trait that can be changed?
Melancholic traits can be inherent or deeply ingrained in a person's temperament, but aspects of this disposition can sometimes be managed or altered with psychological therapy or lifestyle changes.
Can children be melancholic?
Children can exhibit melancholic traits or behaviors, often reflected in unusually serious, reflective, or mature demeanors for their age.
What historical context is associated with the term melancholic?
Historically, melancholic is associated with the ancient theory of the four humors in medicine, where it described one of the personality types believed to be caused by an excess of black bile.
Can melancholy affect one’s physical health?
While melancholy itself is a state of mind, prolonged feelings of sadness and despondency can have physical health implications, such as impacting sleep patterns and overall energy levels.
Do melancholy and sadness mean the same thing?
Melancholy refers to a deeper, more pensive form of sadness that is often enduring and reflective, whereas general sadness can be more fleeting and less intense.
What kind of treatments are effective for melancholic symptoms?
Treatments such as antidepressants, cognitive behavioral therapy, and sometimes electroconvulsive therapy are considered effective for melancholic depression.
What is the impact of being melancholic on social relationships?
Being melancholic might affect social relationships as it can lead to withdrawal and a generally somber demeanor, which might be challenging for interpersonal interactions.
How do melancholic traits manifest in everyday life?
Melancholic traits can manifest as a preference for solitude, a serious demeanor, deep thinking, and an inclination towards pensive sadness.
What role does art play in expressing melancholy or melancholic traits?
Art provides a powerful medium for expressing and exploring melancholy, allowing artists and audiences to process deep emotions through visual, literary, and performative arts.
How does culture influence the perception of melancholic and melancholy?
Cultural attitudes towards emotions and mental health can greatly influence how melancholic traits and melancholy are perceived and treated, ranging from stigma to romanticization.
Share Your Discovery
Previous Comparison
Saunter vs. Wander
Next Comparison
Bologna vs. SalamiAuthor Spotlight
Written by
Fiza RafiqueFiza Rafique is a skilled content writer at AskDifference.com, where she meticulously refines and enhances written pieces. Drawing from her vast editorial expertise, Fiza ensures clarity, accuracy, and precision in every article. Passionate about language, she continually seeks to elevate the quality of content for readers worldwide.
Co-written by
Maham Liaqat
