Paging in OS vs. Segmentation in OS — What's the Difference?
By Tayyaba Rehman — Published on January 15, 2024
Paging in OS divides memory into fixed-size blocks, while Segmentation in OS divides it into variable-size sections based on program requirements.
Difference Between Paging in OS and Segmentation in OS
Table of Contents
ADVERTISEMENT
Key Differences
Paging in OS is a memory management scheme that breaks physical memory into fixed-size blocks known as pages. Segmentation in OS, on the other hand, divides memory into segments based on the different types of data or instructions. Each segment can be of varying lengths, reflecting its actual use and purpose.
In the context of Paging in OS, every page has a fixed size, which simplifies memory management. However, this could lead to internal fragmentation as the last page may not be fully utilized. Segmentation in OS, because it’s based on actual requirements, might not suffer from this kind of waste, but could lead to external fragmentation as memory gets filled with various sized segments.
Another difference is the way memory is accessed. For Paging in OS, the system uses a page table to translate virtual addresses to physical addresses. This table is indexed by page number and provides the base address of each page in physical memory. In Segmentation in OS, the system uses a segment table, which stores the base address of each segment and its length.
When working with Paging in OS, the operating system and the CPU often work together to swap pages in and out of the physical memory and secondary storage, ensuring efficient use of available memory. In contrast, Segmentation in OS might require moving entire segments, which can be more complex due to the variable sizes of segments.
Lastly, Paging in OS is typically invisible to the programmer, requiring no changes in the program. Segmentation in OS, meanwhile, may require the programmer to be aware of the segmentation, especially when dealing with segment references and addressing.
ADVERTISEMENT
Comparison Chart
Size of Division
Fixed-size blocks called pages.
Variable-sized sections based on program needs.
Fragmentation Issues
Can lead to internal fragmentation.
Can result in external fragmentation.
Memory Addressing
Uses a page table to translate virtual to physical addresses.
Uses a segment table for base address and length.
Swapping Complexity
Typically swaps fixed-size pages.
Might require moving entire variable-size segments.
Programmer's Involvement
Typically invisible to the programmer.
Might require programmer's awareness for addressing.
Compare with Definitions
Paging in OS
Paging in OS is a technique of breaking memory into small fixed-size blocks.
To manage memory efficiently, the system uses Paging in OS to allocate and deallocate memory blocks.
Segmentation in OS
Segmentation in OS can lead to external fragmentation over time.
Over prolonged use, the memory can get scattered with gaps in Segmentation in OS, requiring defragmentation.
Paging in OS
Paging in OS aids in abstracting physical memory into a virtual space for processes.
Thanks to Paging in OS, applications can run without being aware of the actual physical memory locations.
Segmentation in OS
Segmentation in OS uses a segment table for memory addressing.
To find a specific function's memory address, the system checks the segment table in Segmentation in OS.
Paging in OS
In Paging in OS, each page is a contiguous block of memory.
With Paging in OS, the memory access is sequential within each individual page.
Segmentation in OS
Segmentation in OS divides memory based on logical divisions like functions or data types.
Segmentation in OS allows a programmer to allocate a specific memory segment for array data.
Paging in OS
Paging in OS reduces the complexity of memory management by using fixed-size blocks.
The standardization introduced by Paging in OS simplifies the memory allocation process.
Segmentation in OS
Segmentation in OS aims to give a more intuitive memory management approach.
With Segmentation in OS, a function can reside entirely in a single segment, making it easier to manage.
Paging in OS
Paging in OS can lead to internal fragmentation if a page is not fully utilized.
Despite the benefits of Paging in OS, a page that's not fully filled can waste memory.
Segmentation in OS
Segmentation in OS involves memory sections of varying lengths.
Unlike fixed-size pages, Segmentation in OS tailors memory blocks to specific needs.
Common Curiosities
How does Segmentation in OS handle memory?
Segmentation in OS divides memory into variable-size sections based on logical divisions like data types or functions.
How does Paging in OS address memory?
Paging in OS uses a page table to translate virtual addresses to physical addresses.
Is Segmentation in OS free from fragmentation issues?
No, Segmentation in OS can result in external fragmentation due to variable segment sizes.
Why might one prefer Segmentation in OS over Paging in OS?
Segmentation in OS offers a more intuitive memory division based on program structure, making it more meaningful for certain applications.
How does Segmentation in OS differ in memory addressing from Paging in OS?
Segmentation in OS uses a segment table, which provides the base address and length of each segment.
What's the primary purpose of Paging in OS?
Paging in OS serves to break physical memory into fixed-size blocks for easier management.
Can Paging in OS lead to wastage of memory?
Yes, Paging in OS can cause internal fragmentation if a page isn't fully utilized.
Can Paging in OS and Segmentation in OS be combined?
Yes, many systems use a combination called paged segmentation, incorporating benefits of both.
Is Paging in OS always of a fixed size?
Yes, by definition, Paging in OS divides memory into fixed-size blocks or pages.
Is Paging in OS more complex for programmers compared to Segmentation in OS?
Typically, Paging in OS is invisible to programmers, while Segmentation in OS might require more programmer awareness.
How does Segmentation in OS determine segment sizes?
Segmentation in OS sizes segments based on logical divisions or requirements, like a function or an array.
Can segments in Segmentation in OS be shared?
Yes, in Segmentation in OS, segments like shared libraries or shared data can be accessed by multiple processes.
Can processes share pages in Paging in OS?
Yes, in Paging in OS, certain pages, like those containing shared libraries, can be shared among processes.
Share Your Discovery
Previous Comparison
Free Software vs. Freeware
Next Comparison
Time Sharing Operating System vs. Real-Time Operating SystemAuthor Spotlight
Written by
Tayyaba RehmanTayyaba Rehman is a distinguished writer, currently serving as a primary contributor to askdifference.com. As a researcher in semantics and etymology, Tayyaba's passion for the complexity of languages and their distinctions has found a perfect home on the platform. Tayyaba delves into the intricacies of language, distinguishing between commonly confused words and phrases, thereby providing clarity for readers worldwide.
