Piano vs. Xylophone — What's the Difference?
Edited by Tayyaba Rehman — By Maham Liaqat — Updated on April 4, 2024
The piano, a versatile string instrument, produces sound via hammers striking strings, while the xylophone, a percussive instrument, generates tones when mallets hit wooden bars.
Difference Between Piano and Xylophone
Table of Contents
ADVERTISEMENT
Key Differences
The piano, known for its wide range and dynamic capabilities, uses a complex mechanism of hammers striking strings to produce sound, offering nuanced expression through touch sensitivity. On the other hand, the xylophone consists of tuned wooden bars struck by mallets, with its sound characterized by a bright, clear tone, largely dependent on the material of the bars and the hardness of the mallets used.
While the piano encompasses a broad musical spectrum, allowing for the performance of both melody and harmony simultaneously due to its polyphonic nature, the xylophone typically plays melodic lines or acts as a percussion instrument in an ensemble, highlighting rhythmic patterns and melodies without the same harmonic depth.
In terms of historical evolution, the piano, invented in the early 18th century by Bartolomeo Cristofori, has undergone significant development, becoming a central instrument in Western music for solo and ensemble performances. The xylophone, with a history that spans several cultures and centuries, retains a more straightforward design, reflecting its roots in early music traditions.
The piano's role in music education and performance is substantial, serving as a foundational instrument for learning music theory, composition, and performance skills. Conversely, the xylophone offers a more accessible entry point for percussion training, emphasizing rhythm and coordination, often used in educational settings for these purposes.
From a physical standpoint, pianos are large, stationary instruments requiring considerable space and maintenance, including regular tuning. Xylophones, while varying in size, are generally more portable and require less maintenance, making them suited for a variety of settings, from classrooms to concert stages.
ADVERTISEMENT
Comparison Chart
Type
String instrument
Percussion instrument
Sound Production
Hammers striking strings
Mallets striking wooden bars
Range and Dynamics
Wide range, dynamic control
Bright, clear tone, less dynamic range
Historical Development
Invented in the early 18th century
Ancient origins, used in multiple cultures
Role in Music
Central in Western music, solo and ensemble
Melodic and rhythmic in ensembles
Education
Foundational for music theory and performance
Used for rhythm and coordination training
Physical Characteristics
Large, requires space and maintenance
More portable, less maintenance required
Compare with Definitions
Piano
A large keyboard instrument where sound is produced by hammers striking strings.
She practiced her scales on the piano every day.
Xylophone
A percussion instrument consisting of wooden bars struck by mallets.
The child enjoyed playing simple melodies on the xylophone.
Piano
Known for its dynamic range and expressive capabilities.
The concert pianist showcased the piano's dynamic nuances beautifully.
Xylophone
Produces a distinctive bright and clear tone.
The xylophone's clear tones punctuated the orchestra's performance.
Piano
Requires regular tuning and maintenance.
The piano tuner came to adjust the instrument's pitch and timbre.
Xylophone
Often used in education to teach rhythm and coordination.
The music class used a xylophone to introduce students to basic rhythms.
Piano
A central piece in both solo and ensemble performances.
The piano concerto featured the instrument as the soloist with orchestral accompaniment.
Xylophone
Portable and suited for various performance settings.
The percussionist brought her xylophone to the outdoor concert.
Piano
Serves as a fundamental instrument in music education.
Learning the piano helps understand music theory and harmony.
Xylophone
Plays melodic lines or enhances rhythm in ensembles.
In the band, the xylophone added an intriguing texture to the melody.
Piano
The piano is an acoustic, stringed musical instrument invented in Italy by Bartolomeo Cristofori around the year 1700 (the exact year is uncertain), in which the strings are struck by wooden hammers that are coated with a softer material (modern hammers are covered with dense wool felt; some early pianos used leather). It is played using a keyboard, which is a row of keys (small levers) that the performer presses down or strikes with the fingers and thumbs of both hands to cause the hammers to strike the strings.
Xylophone
The xylophone (from the Greek words ξύλον—xylon, "wood" + φωνή—phōnē, "sound, voice", literally meaning "sound of wood") is a musical instrument in the percussion family that consists of wooden bars struck by mallets. Like the glockenspiel, the xylophone essentially consists of a set of tuned keys arranged in the fashion of the keyboard of a piano.
Piano
A large keyboard musical instrument with a wooden case enclosing a soundboard and metal strings, which are struck by hammers when the keys are depressed. The strings' vibration is stopped by dampers when the keys are released and can be regulated for length and volume by two or three pedals.
Xylophone
A percussion instrument consisting of a mounted row of wooden bars that are graduated in length to sound a chromatic scale, played with two small mallets.
Piano
A passage performed or marked to be performed softly.
Xylophone
(musical instrument) Any musical instrument (percussion idiophone) made of wooden slats graduated so as to make the sounds of the scale when struck with a small drumstick-like mallet; the standard Western concert xylophone or one of its derivatives.
Piano
(especially as a direction) soft or softly.
Xylophone
To play a xylophone or to play something else as though it was a xylophone.
Piano
(especially as a direction) soft or softly.
Xylophone
To move above a ridged surface so as to hit every ridge, in a manner similar to playing quickly and sequentially on a xylophone.
Piano
A musical instrument with a manual keyboard actuating hammers that strike wire strings, producing sounds that may be softened or sustained by means of pedals.
Xylophone
An instrument common among the Russians, Poles, and Tartars, consisting of a series of strips of wood or glass graduated in length to the musical scale, resting on belts of straw, and struck with two small hammers. Called in Germany strohfiedel, or straw fiddle.
Piano
A passage to be played softly or quietly.
Xylophone
An instrument to determine the vibrative properties of different kinds of wood.
Piano
In a soft or quiet tone. Used chiefly as a direction.
Xylophone
A percussion instrument with wooden bars tuned to produce a chromatic scale and with resonators; played with small mallets
Piano
(musical instruments) a percussive keyboard musical instrument, usually ranging over seven octaves, with white and black colored keys, played by pressing these keys, causing hammers to strike strings
The piano in his house takes up a lot of space.
She has been taking lessons for many years and now plays piano very well.
Piano
To play the piano.
Piano
(of or with fingers) To move (the fingers) up and down on, similar to the motions of a pianist playing the piano.
Piano
To equip with a piano.
Piano
To become softer and less intense.
Piano
(music) softly, as a musical direction (abbreviated to p. in sheet music)
Piano
(music) Soft, quiet.
Piano
(in extended use) Gentle, soft, subdued.
Piano
Soft; - a direction to the performer to execute a certain passage softly, and with diminished volume of tone. (Abbrev. p.
Piano
A well-known musical instrument somewhat resembling the harpsichord, and consisting of a series of wires of graduated length, thickness, and tension, struck by hammers moved by keys.
Piano
A stringed instrument that is played by depressing keys that cause hammers to strike tuned strings and produce sounds
Piano
(music) low loudness
Piano
Used chiefly as a direction or description in music;
The piano passages in the composition
Piano
Used as a direction in music; to be played relatively softly
Common Curiosities
Is the piano considered a percussion instrument?
Though it uses hammers to strike strings, the piano is classified as a string instrument due to its method of sound production and its musical role.
Can a xylophone produce harmony like a piano?
While a xylophone can play chords, its capacity for harmony is more limited compared to the polyphonic capabilities of the piano.
What distinguishes a piano from a xylophone?
The piano is a string instrument with dynamic range and expressiveness, while the xylophone is a percussive instrument known for its bright, clear tones.
How do you maintain a xylophone compared to a piano?
A xylophone requires minimal maintenance, mainly involving the care of its bars and mallets, while a piano needs regular tuning and can require repairs to its mechanical parts.
Which instrument is older, the piano or the xylophone?
The xylophone has ancient origins and is older, while the piano was invented in the early 18th century.
Can both instruments be used in all music genres?
Both instruments are versatile, but their use varies by genre, with the piano prevalent in classical, jazz, and popular music, and the xylophone more common in classical and world music.
Are there different types of pianos and xylophones?
Yes, pianos come in various forms like grand, upright, and digital, while xylophones vary in size, range, and the material of the bars.
How do performers play dynamics on a xylophone?
Dynamics on a xylophone are controlled by the force of the mallet strike and the choice of mallet hardness, though it offers less dynamic range than the piano.
What types of mallets are used for xylophones?
Mallets for xylophones vary in hardness, from soft to hard, affecting the instrument's tone and volume.
How does the material of a xylophone's bars affect its sound?
The material (wood, composite) impacts the tone, volume, and resonance of the xylophone, with harder materials producing brighter tones.
Is it easier to start learning music with a piano or a xylophone?
Starting with a xylophone might be easier for young children due to its simplicity and focus on rhythm, but the piano provides a more comprehensive foundation in music theory.
How do the sizes of pianos and xylophones compare?
Pianos are generally larger and require more space, whereas xylophones are more compact and portable.
Can the piano and xylophone be played solo?
Yes, both instruments can be played solo, with the piano offering a wider range of musical expression and the xylophone focusing on melody and rhythm.
Do pianos and xylophones appear in orchestras?
Both can appear in orchestras; the piano as a solo or ensemble instrument, and the xylophone primarily in the percussion section.
Which instrument is more challenging to master?
Both instruments present unique challenges; mastering the piano requires control over a wide range of keys and dynamics, while the xylophone demands precision in striking and rhythm.
Share Your Discovery
Previous Comparison
Tree vs. ThreeNext Comparison
Seagull vs. SeahawkAuthor Spotlight
Written by
Maham LiaqatEdited by
Tayyaba RehmanTayyaba Rehman is a distinguished writer, currently serving as a primary contributor to askdifference.com. As a researcher in semantics and etymology, Tayyaba's passion for the complexity of languages and their distinctions has found a perfect home on the platform. Tayyaba delves into the intricacies of language, distinguishing between commonly confused words and phrases, thereby providing clarity for readers worldwide.