Protectorate vs. Colony — What's the Difference?
By Tayyaba Rehman & Urooj Arif — Updated on March 14, 2024
A protectorate is a state controlled and protected by another, retaining internal autonomy, while a colony is a territory governed and exploited by a foreign power, often with settlers from the colonizing country.
Difference Between Protectorate and Colony
Table of Contents
ADVERTISEMENT
Key Differences
A protectorate refers to a region or country that maintains its own internal government but is under the control or protection of an external sovereign state. On the other hand, a colony is a territory acquired and governed by a foreign sovereign power, where the colonizing country often settles its population, extracts resources, and imposes its own government and legal system, significantly limiting or eliminating the colony's autonomy.
Protectorates retain a degree of self-governance and local customs, with the protecting power usually handling only defense and foreign policy. In contrast, colonies are directly ruled by the colonizing nation, with significant control over governance, economic policies, and often, social structures, aiming to benefit the colonizer.
The establishment of a protectorate often stems from a desire to influence without the expense and responsibility of full colonization. It provides a form of indirect rule that can be seen as less intrusive. Colonies, however, are established through direct control, with the intent of economic exploitation, strategic advantage, or settlement expansion, reflecting a more direct form of imperialism.
Culturally, protectorates might preserve a greater degree of their indigenous traditions and social systems, whereas colonies experience more substantial cultural and demographic changes due to colonization efforts, including settlement, resource extraction, and the imposition of the colonizer's culture and institutions.
The transition from a protectorate or colony to independence varies significantly. Protectorates may gain full sovereignty through negotiation or shifts in geopolitical power. Colonies often achieve independence through a longer process involving political struggle, negotiation, and sometimes conflict, reflecting their deeper integration into and exploitation by the colonizing power.
ADVERTISEMENT
Comparison Chart
Sovereignty
Limited; retains internal government
Largely controlled by foreign power
Governance
Local governance with external protection
Direct rule by colonizing nation
Establishment Reason
Protection, economic assistance
Economic exploitation, strategic advantage
Cultural Impact
Preserves more indigenous traditions
Greater cultural and demographic changes
Path to Independence
Through negotiation or geopolitical shifts
Often through political struggle or conflict
Compare with Definitions
Protectorate
A protectorate is a state that retains its own government but is under the protection of a more powerful state.
The small kingdom became a protectorate to avoid military invasion.
Colony
A colony is a territory under the full or partial political control of another country.
The overseas territories were colonies, exploited for their resources.
Protectorate
Protectorates often involve a formal agreement for protection and foreign affairs.
The treaty established the region as a protectorate, ensuring its defense.
Colony
The colonizer imposes its governance and laws.
In the colony, the colonizer's laws superseded local customs.
Protectorate
It allows for a degree of autonomy while being protected.
As a protectorate, it maintained its cultural practices while benefiting from economic aid.
Colony
Independence often follows a struggle.
The colony fought for and achieved its independence after decades of resistance.
Protectorate
The protecting state handles international relations.
The protectorate's foreign policies were managed by its powerful ally.
Colony
Colonies are often settled by the colonizing country's citizens.
Settlers from the empire established a new colony on the continent.
Protectorate
Transition to full sovereignty can be peaceful.
The protectorate gained independence through diplomatic negotiations with its protector.
Colony
Economic exploitation is a key feature of colonies.
The colony's rich mines were controlled entirely by the colonizing nation.
Protectorate
A protectorate is a state that is controlled and protected by another sovereign state. It is a dependent territory that has been granted local autonomy over most internal affairs while still recognizing the suzerainty of a more powerful sovereign state without being its direct possession.
Colony
A company of people transplanted from their mother country to a remote province or country, and remaining subject to the jurisdiction of the parent state; as, the British colonies in America.
The first settlers of New England were the best of Englishmen, well educated, devout Christians, and zealous lovers of liberty. There was never a colony formed of better materials.
Protectorate
A relationship of protection and partial control assumed by a superior power over a dependent country or region.
Colony
In political science, a colony is a territory subject to a form of foreign rule. Though dominated by the foreign colonizers, colonies remain separate from the administration of the original country of the colonizers, the metropolitan state (or "mother country").
Protectorate
The protected country or region.
Colony
A country or area under the full or partial political control of another country and occupied by settlers from that country
Japanese forces overran the French colony of Indo-China
Protectorate
The government, office, or term of a protector.
Colony
A group of people of one nationality or race living in a foreign place
The British colony in New York
Protectorate
The government of England under Oliver Cromwell and his son Richard, ruling as Lord Protector of the Commonwealth.
Colony
A community of animals or plants of one kind living close together or forming a physically connected structure
A colony of seals
Protectorate
Government by a protector; especially, the government of England, Scotland, and Ireland by Oliver Cromwell.
Colony
A group of emigrants or their descendants who settle in a distant territory but remain subject to or closely associated with the parent country.
Protectorate
The authority assumed by a superior power over an inferior or a dependent one, whereby the former protects the latter from invasion and shares in the management of its affairs but the protected state retains its nominal sovereignty.
Egypt became a British protectorate in 1914.
Colony
A territory thus settled.
Protectorate
An autonomous territory that is protected diplomatically or militarily against third parties by a stronger state or entity.
Colony
A region politically controlled by a distant country; a dependency.
Protectorate
Government by a protector; - applied especially to the government of England by Oliver Cromwell.
Colony
A group of people with the same interests or ethnic origin concentrated in a particular area
The American colony in Paris.
Protectorate
The authority assumed by a superior power over an inferior or a dependent one, whereby the former protects the latter from invasion and shares in the management of its affairs.
Colony
The area occupied by such a group.
Protectorate
A state or territory partly controlled by (but not a possession of) a stronger state but autonomous in internal affairs; protectorates are established by treaty
Colony
Colonies The British colonies that became the original 13 states of the United States.
Colony
A group of people who have been institutionalized in a relatively remote area
An island penal colony.
Colony
A group of the same kind of animals, plants, or one-celled organisms living or growing together.
Colony
A visible growth of microorganisms, usually in a solid or semisolid nutrient medium.
Colony
An area under the political control of another country and typically occupied by settlers (colonists) from it, or by their descendants.
Much of the eastern United States was formerly a British colony; other areas were French, Spanish, Dutch, or Swedish colonies.
Bermuda is a crown colony of Great Britain.
Colony
A group of people who settle such an area and maintain ties to their native country, and (later) their descendants.
Colony
A group of people, of one nationality, ethnic group, or language, residing in a different country, city, or area; the area such people occupy.
A colony of British expats in Spain
The Amana Colonies in Iowa were settled by people from Germany.
Colony
A group of people with similar interests, occupations, or characteristics, living in a particular area; the area such people occupy.
A nudist colony; the statue was put up right in the middle of the artist colony
A leper colony on the outskirts of town; most buildings in the penal colony were made of concrete
Colony
(biology) A group of organisms of same or different species living together in close association.
Ant colony; coral colony
A colony of specialized polyps and medusoids
Colony
A group of bacteria, fungi or other cells cultured together, especially from a single cell.
Colonies of stem cells
Colony
(India) An apartment complex or neighborhood.
Our colony is quite small, but each apartment is large.
Colony
A local group of Beaver Scouts.
Colony
A potential new chapter of a fraternity or sorority awaiting official recognition from their headquarters.
Colony
The district or country colonized; a settlement.
Colony
A territory subject to the ruling governmental authority of another country and not a part of the ruling country.
Colony
A company of persons from the same country sojourning in a foreign city or land; as, the American colony in Paris.
Colony
A number of animals or plants living or growing together, beyond their usual range.
Colony
A cell family or group of common origin, mostly of unicellular organisms, esp. among the lower algæ. They may adhere in chains or groups, or be held together by a gelatinous envelope.
Colony
A cluster or aggregation of zooids of any compound animal, as in the corals, hydroids, certain tunicates, etc.
Colony
A community of social insects, as ants, bees, etc.
Colony
A group of microorganisms originating as the descendents of one individual cell, growing on a gelled growth medium, as of gelatin or agar; especially, such a group that has grown to a sufficient number to be visible to the naked eye.
Colony
A body of people who settle far from home but maintain ties with their homeland; inhabitants remain nationals of their home state but are not literally under the home state's system of government
Colony
A group of animals of the same type living together
Colony
One of the 13 British colonies that formed the original states of the United States
Colony
A geographical area politically controlled by a distant country
Colony
(microbiology) a group of organisms grown from a single parent cell
Common Curiosities
Why would a country prefer to be a protectorate rather than a colony?
Being a protectorate allows for more internal autonomy and the preservation of local governance and customs, as opposed to the direct control and exploitation experienced by colonies.
Do protectorates contribute to the economy of the protecting power?
While protectorates can contribute economically, especially through trade agreements, they are less exploited than colonies, which are primarily established for economic gain by the colonizing nation.
How do international relations differ for protectorates and colonies?
Protectorates engage in international relations through the protecting power, whereas colonies have limited to no role in foreign affairs, being directly controlled by the colonizing country.
Can a protectorate have its own military?
Protectorates may have their own military forces, but defense and international security are often the responsibility of the protecting power.
Can a protectorate become a colony?
In some historical contexts, protectorates have transitioned into colonies as the protecting power increased its control, though this is not always the case.
What are examples of modern-day protectorates?
While traditional protectorates are less common today, some territories maintain similar relationships, often through free association agreements with sovereign states, focusing on defense and foreign policy cooperation.
How does the culture of a protectorate compare to that of a colony?
Protectorates are more likely to retain indigenous traditions and social systems, while colonies undergo significant cultural and demographic changes due to the influence and settlement of the colonizing power.
What leads to the establishment of a protectorate?
Protectorates are often established through treaties where a weaker state seeks protection, economic assistance, or political support from a stronger state, giving up certain sovereignties in return.
What is the main difference between a protectorate and a colony?
The main difference lies in the degree of control and autonomy; protectorates retain internal governance with external protection, whereas colonies are territories governed and exploited by a foreign power.
Is the path to independence for a colony different from that of a protectorate?
Yes, protectorates often gain independence through negotiation or geopolitical shifts, while colonies may require political struggle, negotiation, and sometimes conflict to achieve independence.
Share Your Discovery
Previous Comparison
Cleavage vs. Fracture
Next Comparison
Abuse vs. NeglectAuthor Spotlight
Written by
Tayyaba RehmanTayyaba Rehman is a distinguished writer, currently serving as a primary contributor to askdifference.com. As a researcher in semantics and etymology, Tayyaba's passion for the complexity of languages and their distinctions has found a perfect home on the platform. Tayyaba delves into the intricacies of language, distinguishing between commonly confused words and phrases, thereby providing clarity for readers worldwide.
Co-written by
Urooj ArifUrooj is a skilled content writer at Ask Difference, known for her exceptional ability to simplify complex topics into engaging and informative content. With a passion for research and a flair for clear, concise writing, she consistently delivers articles that resonate with our diverse audience.
