Province vs. Prefecture — What's the Difference?
By Tayyaba Rehman & Maham Liaqat — Updated on March 27, 2024
A province is an administrative division within a country, varying widely in autonomy and size, while a prefecture is used in specific countries like Japan and France, denoting a jurisdictional area governed more directly by the central government.
Difference Between Province and Prefecture
Table of Contents
ADVERTISEMENT
Key Differences
Provinces are significant administrative divisions within a country, often having their own local government, laws, and sometimes even official languages. These entities play a crucial role in managing regional affairs and decentralizing power from the national government. On the other hand, prefectures, particularly noted in countries like Japan, France, and historically in China, are also administrative divisions but tend to have a closer relationship with the central government, with varying degrees of autonomy and administrative powers depending on the country's specific governance system.
While provinces can be found in many countries around the world, with their roles and powers varying greatly depending on the country’s constitution and administrative structure, prefectures are more specifically tied to the administrative systems of certain countries. Prefectures in Japan, for example, are integral parts of the country's administrative framework, acting as subdivisions directly under the central government, whereas in France, the term "prefecture" refers to the office of the prefect and its jurisdiction, representing the state at the local level.
Provinces usually cover larger geographical areas and have a broader scope of governance, dealing with a wide range of regional issues from infrastructure to education. Prefectures, however, might cover smaller or similar-sized areas but often have a governance model that emphasizes the implementation of central government policies and direct administrative control by appointed officials rather than elected regional representatives.
In terms of autonomy, provinces typically enjoy a greater degree of self-governance, with elected officials and the ability to enact local legislation within the framework of the national constitution. Prefectures, conversely, often have leaders appointed by the central government, emphasizing the role of these divisions in extending central control and ensuring uniformity in administrative practices and policies across the country.
Comparison Chart
Definition
An administrative division with varying degrees of autonomy.
An administrative division with direct governance by the central government.
ADVERTISEMENT
Autonomy
Generally high, with local governments and possibly its own laws.
Varies, but often involves more direct control by the central government.
Geographic Scope
Can be large, covering substantial parts of a country.
Size varies, but is defined by national law and often covers smaller areas than provinces.
Governance
Often has elected officials and self-governance capabilities.
Usually governed by officials appointed by the central government.
Example Countries
Canada, Italy, China (for its broader administrative areas).
Japan, France (for the departmental system), and historically in China.
Compare with Definitions
Province
A territorial unit for administrative purposes within a country.
Ontario is a province known for its diverse culture and economy in Canada.
Prefecture
Regions implementing central government policies directly.
In Japan, prefectures handle local implementation of national education standards.
Province
An area designated for local governance, varying widely in autonomy.
The Argentine province of Buenos Aires is significant for its economic contribution.
Prefecture
An administrative jurisdiction or division in certain countries.
Kyoto Prefecture in Japan is famous for its historical sites.
Province
Administrative regions with historical or cultural significance.
The province of Yunnan in China is renowned for its biodiversity.
Prefecture
A district under the government's direct control, often smaller than a province.
The Prefecture of Police in Paris oversees the city's law enforcement.
Province
A region with its own local government within a larger country.
The province of Punjab plays a crucial role in Pakistan's agriculture.
Prefecture
A territorial division managed by appointed officials.
Hiroshima Prefecture is a testament to peace and resilience.
Province
A division that can enact regional laws under a national framework.
In the Philippines, each province has a governor and a provincial board.
Prefecture
An administrative level, particularly in Japan and France, focusing on centralized governance.
The Ile-de-France prefecture encompasses Paris and its suburban areas.
Province
A province is almost always an administrative division within a country or state. The term derives from the ancient Roman provincia, which was the major territorial and administrative unit of the Roman Empire's territorial possessions outside Italy.
Prefecture
A prefecture (from the Latin Praefectura) is an administrative jurisdiction traditionally governed by an appointed prefect. This can be a regional or local government subdivision in various countries, or a subdivision in certain international church structures, as well as in antiquity a Roman district.
Province
A principal administrative division of a country or empire
Chengdu, capital of Sichuan province
Prefecture
The district administered or governed by a prefect.
Province
The whole of a country outside the capital, especially when regarded as lacking in sophistication or culture
I made my way home to the dreary provinces by train
Prefecture
An administrative district of some countries, especially China or Japan.
Province
An area of special knowledge, interest, or responsibility
She knew little about wine—that had been her father's province
Prefecture
The office or authority of a prefect.
Province
A territory governed as an administrative or political unit of a country or empire.
Prefecture
The residence or housing of a prefect.
Province
(Ecclesiastical) A division of territory under the jurisdiction of a metropolitan.
Prefecture
The office or position of a prefect.
Province
Provinces Areas of a country situated away from the capital or population center.
Prefecture
The jurisdiction of a prefect; the region administered by a prefect, especially as a translation of certain French, Chinese, and Japanese administrative divisions.
Province
An area of knowledge, activity, or interest
A topic falling within the province of ancient history.
Prefecture
The office, position, or jurisdiction of a prefect; also, his official residence.
Province
The range of one's proper duties and functions; scope.
Prefecture
The district administered by a prefect (as in France or Japan or the Roman Empire)
Province
(Ecology) An area of land, less extensive than a region, having a characteristic plant and animal population.
Prefecture
The office of prefect
Province
Any of various lands outside Italy conquered by the Romans and administered by them as self-contained units.
Province
A region of the earth or of a continent; a district or country.
Province
An administrative subdivision of certain countries, including Canada and China.
Province
(Roman history) An area outside Italy which is administered by a Roman governor.
Province
(Christianity) An area under the jurisdiction of an archbishop, typically comprising a number of adjacent dioceses.
Province
(Roman Catholicism) An area under the jurisdiction of a provincial within a monastic order.
Province
The parts of a country outside its capital city.
Province
An area of activity, responsibility or knowledge; the proper concern of a particular person or concept.
Province
A country or region, more or less remote from the city of Rome, brought under the Roman government; a conquered country beyond the limits of Italy.
Province
A country or region dependent on a distant authority; a portion of an empire or state, esp. one remote from the capital.
Province
A region of country; a tract; a district.
Over many a tractof heaven they marched, and many a province wide.
Other provinces of the intellectual world.
Province
A region under the supervision or direction of any special person; the district or division of a country, especially an ecclesiastical division, over which one has jurisdiction; as, the province of Canterbury, or that in which the archbishop of Canterbury exercises ecclesiastical authority.
Province
The proper or appropriate business or duty of a person or body; office; charge; jurisdiction; sphere.
The woman'sprovince is to be careful in her economy, and chaste in her affection.
Province
Specif.: Any political division of the Dominion of Canada, having a governor, a local legislature, and representation in the Dominion parliament. Hence, colloquially, The Provinces, the Dominion of Canada.
Province
The territory occupied by one of the constituent administrative districts of a nation;
His state is in the deep south
Province
The proper sphere or extent of your activities;
It was his province to take care of himself
Common Curiosities
Can a prefecture have the same level of autonomy as a province?
This varies by country, but typically prefectures have less autonomy compared to provinces due to their closer ties with the central government.
How do provinces and prefectures contribute to national governance?
They help decentralize governance, allowing for more localized administration of services and policies, though prefectures tend to ensure greater uniformity in applying national policies.
Are prefectures unique to Japan?
While prefectures are most commonly associated with Japan, other countries like France also use this term or a similar administrative system, albeit with different structures and functions.
How are officials chosen for governance in provinces and prefectures?
In provinces, officials are often elected locally, whereas in prefectures, officials are more likely to be appointed by the central government.
Why do countries choose different administrative divisions like provinces or prefectures?
The choice reflects historical, cultural, and governance preferences, aiming to balance local autonomy with national unity and effective administration.
What is the main difference between a province and a prefecture?
The main difference lies in their level of autonomy and relation to the central government, with provinces generally having more self-governance and prefectures being more directly controlled by the national government.
Is there a hierarchy between provinces and prefectures within a country?
Generally, they exist as parallel structures suited to different administrative models and are not hierarchical relative to each other but to the national government.
Do all countries have provinces and prefectures?
No, the use of provinces and prefectures depends on the country's administrative and legal framework. Some countries may use other terms like states, regions, or counties.
Can the size of a province and a prefecture be compared?
Size can vary greatly, but generally, provinces cover larger areas than prefectures, although this is not a strict rule and depends on the country.
How does the role of a province or prefecture affect local culture and identity?
Both can significantly influence local culture and identity through governance, policies, and the promotion of regional heritage, although the impact varies based on their autonomy and functions.
Share Your Discovery
Previous Comparison
Enterprise vs. Organization
Next Comparison
Hypersonic vs. UltrasonicAuthor Spotlight
Written by
Tayyaba RehmanTayyaba Rehman is a distinguished writer, currently serving as a primary contributor to askdifference.com. As a researcher in semantics and etymology, Tayyaba's passion for the complexity of languages and their distinctions has found a perfect home on the platform. Tayyaba delves into the intricacies of language, distinguishing between commonly confused words and phrases, thereby providing clarity for readers worldwide.
Co-written by
Maham Liaqat
