Purgatory vs. Limbo — What's the Difference?
By Tayyaba Rehman — Updated on October 2, 2023
Purgatory is a place where souls are cleansed of sin before heaven, while limbo is a state of uncertainty or where unbaptized souls reside.
Difference Between Purgatory and Limbo
Table of Contents
ADVERTISEMENT
Key Differences
Purgatory, within certain religious beliefs, is described as an intermediate state after physical death where souls are purified from venial sins. It's a process of cleansing, allowing souls to achieve the sanctity necessary for entering heaven. On the other hand, limbo represents a boundary or intermediate state, often of uncertainty or neglect, both in religious and secular contexts.
Limbo has a more varied interpretation. In theology, particularly within Catholicism, limbo is understood as the edge of Hell where unbaptized infants or those who died before Christ's resurrection reside. They don't suffer punishment but lack the joy of God's presence. Contrarily, purgatory is seen as a temporary state for souls who have the assurance of reaching heaven once purified.
In broader, non-religious contexts, limbo implies a situation where something or someone is neglected or in a state of uncertainty, waiting for a decision or resolution. Purgatory, while rooted in religious doctrine, can also metaphorically describe any state or place of temporary suffering or purification.
Both purgatory and limbo, while originating from religious discourse, have permeated into everyday language. They are used metaphorically to describe various situations or states of being. While purgatory often implies undergoing a process with an eventual positive outcome, limbo suggests stagnation without a clear end.
Comparison Chart
Meaning
A state/place of purification after death.
A boundary or intermediate state of uncertainty.
ADVERTISEMENT
Religious Context
Souls cleanse sins before entering heaven.
Edge of Hell; unbaptized souls reside.
Duration
Temporary, until soul is purified.
Indeterminate; possibly permanent.
Metaphorical Use
Describes a state of temporary suffering.
Describes a state of neglect or indecision.
Origin
Latin "purgare" meaning "to cleanse".
Latin "limbus" meaning "edge or boundary".
Compare with Definitions
Purgatory
An intermediate state before final reckoning or judgment.
The company was in financial purgatory awaiting the court's decision.
Limbo
An intermediate or transitional state or place.
The project was in limbo until the funding was approved.
Purgatory
A state in which the souls of those who have died in grace undergo limited torment.
Many believe that prayers can assist souls in purgatory.
Limbo
A dance or game where participants lean backward to pass under a bar.
The beach party included a fun game of limbo.
Purgatory
An intermediate state after death for purification from sin.
Her belief was that souls undergo a transformation in purgatory.
Limbo
A situation in which progress is impossible.
Negotiations seemed in limbo after the disagreement.
Purgatory
A place or state of temporary suffering or misery.
The long wait for the test results felt like purgatory.
Limbo
A place in some Christian beliefs for unbaptized souls.
Some theologians theorize about limbo as a space for unbaptized infants.
Purgatory
Purgatory (Latin: purgatorium, borrowed into English via Anglo-Norman and Old French) is, according to the belief of some Christians (mostly Catholics), an intermediate state after physical death for expiatory purification. The process of purgatory is the final purification of the elect, which is entirely different from the punishment of the damned.
Limbo
In Catholic theology, Limbo (Latin limbus, edge or boundary, referring to the edge of Hell) is the viewpoint concerning the afterlife condition of those who die in original sin without being assigned to the Hell of the Damned. Medieval theologians of Western Europe described the underworld ("hell", "hades", "infernum") as divided into four distinct parts: Hell of the Damned, Purgatory, Limbo of the Fathers or Patriarchs, and Limbo of the Infants.
Purgatory
(in Catholic doctrine) a place or state of suffering inhabited by the souls of sinners who are expiating their sins before going to heaven
The punishment of souls in purgatory
All her sins were forgiven and she would not need to go to Purgatory
Limbo
Often Limbo Roman Catholic Church The abode of unbaptized but innocent or righteous souls, as those of infants or virtuous individuals who lived before the coming of Christ.
Purgatory
Having the quality of cleansing or purifying
Infernal punishments are purgatory and medicinal
Limbo
A condition of prolonged uncertainty or neglect
Management kept her promotion in limbo for months.
Purgatory
Roman Catholic Church A state in which the souls of those who have died in grace must expiate their sins.
Limbo
A West Indian dance in which the dancers repeatedly bend over backward and pass under a pole that is lowered slightly with each pass.
Purgatory
A place or condition of suffering, expiation, or remorse
A purgatory of drug abuse.
Limbo
To place (someone or something) in an in-between place, or condition or state, of neglect or oblivion which results in deadlock, delay, or some other unresolved status.
Purgatory
Tending to cleanse or purge.
Limbo
(dances) To dance the limbo (etymology 2, dance).
Purgatory
(Christianity) Purgatory
Limbo
(by extension) Often followed by under: to pass under something while bending backwards.
Purgatory
Any situation where suffering is endured, particularly as part of a process of redemption.
Limbo
The place, thought to be on the edge of the bottomless pit of Hell, where the souls of innocent deceased people exist temporarily until they can enter heaven, specifically those of the saints who died before the advent of Jesus Christ (who occupy the limbo patrum or limbo of the patriarchs or fathers) and those of unbaptized infants (who occupy the limbo infantum or limbo of the infants); (countable) the place where each category of souls exists, regarded separately.
Purgatory
Tending to cleanse; expiatory.
Limbo
(by extension)
Purgatory
Tending to cleanse; cleansing; expiatory.
Limbo
Chiefly preceded by in: any in-between place, or condition or state, of neglect or oblivion which results in deadlock, delay, or some other unresolved status.
My passport application has been stuck in bureaucratic limbo for two weeks.
Purgatory
A state or place of purification after death; according to the Roman Catholic creed, a place, or a state believed to exist after death, in which the souls of persons are purified by expiating such offenses committed in this life as do not merit eternal damnation, or in which they fully satisfy the justice of God for sins that have been forgiven. After this purgation from the impurities of sin, the souls are believed to be received into heaven.
Limbo
Jail, prison; (countable) a jail cell or lockup.
Purgatory
A temporary condition of torment or suffering;
A purgatory of drug abuse
Limbo
Synonym of Hadesor Hell
Purgatory
(theology) in Roman Catholic theology the place where those who have died in a state of grace undergo limited torment to expiate their sins
Limbo
Synonym of pawn
Purgatory
A process of purification or temporary punishment.
The grueling training was his purgatory before the actual marathon.
Limbo
A type of antisubmarine mortar installed on naval vessels.
Limbo
A competitive dance originating from Trinidad and Tobago in which dancers take turns to cross under a horizontal bar while bending backwards. The bar is lowered with each round, and the competition is won by the dancer who passes under the bar in the lowest position without dislodging it or falling down.
Limbo
An spiritual region where certain classes of souls were supposed to await the last judgment.
As far from help as Limbo is from bliss.
A Limbo large and broad, since calledThe Paradise of fools.
Limbo
Hence: Any real or imaginary place of restraint or confinement; a prison; as, to put a man in limbo.
Limbo
A state of waiting, or uncertainty, in which final judgment concerning the outcome of a decision is postponed, perhaps indefinitely; neglect for an indefinite time; as, the proposal was left in limbo while opponents and proponents refused to compromise.
Limbo
A border or margin; as, the limbus of the cornea.
Limbo
A West Indian dance contest, in which participants must dance under a pole which is lowered successively until only one participant can successfully pass under, without falling. It is often performed at celebrations, such as weddings.
Limbo
The state of being disregarded or forgotten
Limbo
An imaginary place for lost or neglected things
Limbo
(theology) in Roman Catholicism, the place of unbaptized but innocent or righteous souls (such as infants and virtuous individuals)
Limbo
A state of uncertainty or oblivion.
Without proper documentation, his application was left in limbo.
Common Curiosities
Do all Christians believe in purgatory?
No, the concept of purgatory is primarily associated with Catholicism and is not universally accepted among all Christian denominations.
Does purgatory imply eventual entry to heaven?
Yes, souls in purgatory are believed to eventually enter heaven after purification.
Can limbo be used in a non-religious context?
Yes, "in limbo" can describe any situation of uncertainty or indecision.
What's the primary distinction between purgatory and limbo?
Purgatory is for soul purification after death, while limbo is a state of uncertainty or where unbaptized souls reside.
Are both purgatory and limbo Catholic beliefs?
While both concepts exist in Catholicism, purgatory is a more universally accepted doctrine than limbo.
Is limbo considered a permanent state?
In religious context, it's uncertain; in secular usage, it implies an indefinite state of waiting.
Can "in limbo" describe a project's state?
Yes, projects "in limbo" are in a state of uncertainty or waiting.
Does everyone go to purgatory after death?
According to Catholic doctrine, only souls that aren't perfectly cleansed of venial sins but are in a state of grace undergo purification in purgatory.
How did the concept of purgatory originate?
It has roots in biblical scriptures and has been developed and defined over time by church theologians.
Is limbo the same as the edge of Hell?
In some theological interpretations, yes, limbo is considered the edge of Hell.
Is purgatory considered a second chance for souls?
It's more of a purification process for souls already destined for heaven, not a second chance for damnation reversal.
Can one pray for souls in purgatory?
Yes, in Catholic belief, prayers can aid souls in their purification process.
Can the concept of purgatory be found in other religions?
While specific beliefs vary, similar concepts of an intermediate state post-death exist in other religions.
How do purgatory and limbo relate to heaven and hell?
Purgatory is a temporary state before heaven, while limbo, in some beliefs, is an edge of Hell or a separate state altogether.
Is limbo a place of punishment?
No, it's described as a state without suffering but also without the joy of God's presence.
Share Your Discovery
Previous Comparison
Hot vs. SunnyNext Comparison
Province vs. RegionAuthor Spotlight
Written by
Tayyaba RehmanTayyaba Rehman is a distinguished writer, currently serving as a primary contributor to askdifference.com. As a researcher in semantics and etymology, Tayyaba's passion for the complexity of languages and their distinctions has found a perfect home on the platform. Tayyaba delves into the intricacies of language, distinguishing between commonly confused words and phrases, thereby providing clarity for readers worldwide.