Schottky Defect vs. Frenkel Defect — What's the Difference?
Edited by Tayyaba Rehman — By Fiza Rafique — Published on January 6, 2024
Schottky Defect involves the absence of equal numbers of cations and anions, forming a vacancy. Frenkel Defect results from a dislocation of an ion to an interstitial site, without creating a vacancy.
Difference Between Schottky Defect and Frenkel Defect
Table of Contents
ADVERTISEMENT
Key Differences
In the realm of crystal structures, both Schottky Defect and Frenkel Defect are types of point defects that arise from irregularities in the arrangement of atoms or ions. A Schottky Defect arises due to the simultaneous absence of a cation and an anion from their respective lattice sites, thus creating a vacancy in the structure. On the other hand, a Frenkel Defect occurs when an ion leaves its regular site and moves to an interstitial site, causing a dislocation without creating a vacancy.
The Schottky Defect is more prevalent in ionic solids with closely-sized cations and anions. Such defects reduce the density of the crystal because of the missing ions. In contrast, a Frenkel Defect is more common in ionic solids where there's a significant difference in the sizes of cations and anions, ensuring easier movement of the smaller ion to interstitial sites.
From an electrical standpoint, both Schottky Defect and Frenkel Defect maintain electrical neutrality in the crystal. In the Schottky Defect, equal numbers of positive and negative ions are missing, preserving neutrality. For the Frenkel Defect, the ion simply moves within the crystal structure without introducing an external charge.
It's worth noting that the formation of a Schottky Defect typically results in a decrease in the crystal's density due to the vacancies. In contrast, the Frenkel Defect doesn't bring about a change in density as no ions are missing, but rather repositioned within the crystal.
To encapsulate, while both Schottky Defect and Frenkel Defect are irregularities in crystal structures, the former pertains to missing ions creating vacancies, and the latter involves the dislocation of an ion within the lattice without leaving a vacancy.
ADVERTISEMENT
Comparison Chart
Origin
Absence of cation and anion.
Dislocation of an ion to an interstitial site.
Density Impact
Causes a decrease in density.
No change in density.
Ionic Size Preference
Occurs in solids with closely-sized ions.
Found in solids with a large difference in ionic sizes.
Neutrality
Maintained through equal missing cations and anions.
Maintained as no ion is actually missing.
Example Solids
Common in NaCl and KCl.
Typical in AgCl and ZnS.
Compare with Definitions
Schottky Defect
Equal number of cation and anion vacancies.
Schottky Defect ensures electrical neutrality by having an equal absence of cations and anions.
Frenkel Defect
Common in solids with sizeable ionic size difference.
Frenkel Defects are often found in ionic compounds where cations are much smaller than anions.
Schottky Defect
Point defect reducing crystal density.
Schottky Defects result in reduced density due to the missing ions.
Frenkel Defect
Interstitial defect in ionic crystals.
The dislocation of silver ion in AgCl represents a Frenkel Defect.
Schottky Defect
Common in closely-sized ionic solids.
Ionic compounds like KCl often exhibit Schottky Defects.
Frenkel Defect
Point defect with no change in crystal density.
Despite the dislocation of ions, Frenkel Defect doesn't affect the crystal's overall density.
Schottky Defect
Vacancy defect in ionic crystals.
The absence of paired ions in NaCl is an example of a Schottky Defect.
Frenkel Defect
Defect involving repositioned ions.
When an ion moves from its regular site to an interstitial site, a Frenkel Defect occurs.
Schottky Defect
Defect involving missing ions.
A vacancy created by missing sodium and chloride ions is termed a Schottky Defect.
Frenkel Defect
Defect due to movement of smaller ions.
In ZnS, the smaller zinc ion's movement leads to a Frenkel Defect.
Common Curiosities
What causes Schottky defects?
They can be caused by thermal vibrations, ionizing radiation, or during the crystal's formation.
Can Schottky defects be removed or reduced?
Yes, by heating the crystal and allowing the ions to move back into their lattice positions.
What is a Frenkel defect?
A Frenkel defect arises when an ion (usually a cation) is displaced from its lattice site but remains within the crystal lattice, creating a vacancy and an interstitial.
In which materials is it commonly found?
Schottky defects are commonly found in ionic compounds with closely sized cations and anions, like NaCl and KCl.
How does a Frenkel defect affect the material's conductivity?
It can increase the ionic conductivity as the displaced ion can contribute to ion transport.
How does it affect the density of the material?
The presence of Schottky defects lowers the density of the material due to the missing ions.
What is a Schottky defect?
A Schottky defect arises when equal numbers of cations and anions are missing from a crystal lattice, leading to a vacancy.
Do these defects play a role in the mechanical properties of materials?
Yes, they can influence properties like strength, ductility, and diffusion rates.
How does it differ from a Schottky defect?
In a Frenkel defect, only one ion leaves its position, whereas in a Schottky defect, equal numbers of cations and anions leave their positions.
How do these defects relate to the stoichiometry of the compound?
Both defects preserve the stoichiometry. No atoms or ions are added or removed from the crystal; they only change positions.
Do these defects alter the crystal's overall charge?
No, the overall charge of the crystal remains neutral.
Why are these defects important in material science?
Understanding these defects is crucial for tailoring materials' properties, improving processing techniques, and understanding material behaviors under various conditions.
In which materials is a Frenkel defect commonly found?
It's typically found in ionic compounds with a significant difference in ion sizes, such as AgCl and ZnS.
Are Frenkel defects common in covalent solids?
No, they are primarily observed in ionic solids.
How do temperature and external factors influence these defects?
An increase in temperature can induce or increase the number of these defects. Radiation or other external factors can also introduce defects.
Share Your Discovery
Previous Comparison
Social Service vs. Social Work
Next Comparison
Link vs. AssociationAuthor Spotlight
Written by
Fiza RafiqueFiza Rafique is a skilled content writer at AskDifference.com, where she meticulously refines and enhances written pieces. Drawing from her vast editorial expertise, Fiza ensures clarity, accuracy, and precision in every article. Passionate about language, she continually seeks to elevate the quality of content for readers worldwide.
Edited by
Tayyaba RehmanTayyaba Rehman is a distinguished writer, currently serving as a primary contributor to askdifference.com. As a researcher in semantics and etymology, Tayyaba's passion for the complexity of languages and their distinctions has found a perfect home on the platform. Tayyaba delves into the intricacies of language, distinguishing between commonly confused words and phrases, thereby providing clarity for readers worldwide.
