Shall vs. Will — What's the Difference?
By Tayyaba Rehman — Updated on September 23, 2023
"Shall" traditionally suggests obligation or future actions in the first person, while "will" indicates intention or prediction. Both can denote future tense, but their usage varies in formality and context.
Difference Between Shall and Will
Table of Contents
ADVERTISEMENT
Key Differences
"Shall" and "will" are modal verbs in English that are often used to indicate the future tense. Historically, "shall" was used with the first person (I, we) to express the future, and "will" was used with the second and third person. Conversely, "will" was used with the first person to express determination, while "shall" conveyed this sense with the second and third person.
Over time, especially in American English, this distinction has blurred, and "will" has largely taken over as the primary future marker. "Shall" remains, but its use has become more formal and less common, especially in the United States. When "shall" is used in modern American English, it often indicates a sense of obligation or formality, as in legal documents or certain formal requests.
In contrast, British English has retained a more distinct use of "shall" and "will." In questions, for instance, "shall" can be used with the first person to offer or suggest something, as in "Shall we dance?" On the other hand, "will" in questions can seek more information about the future, like "Will it rain tomorrow?"
It's essential to recognize that while "shall" and "will" have specific traditional distinctions, language evolves. Today, the choice between "shall" and "will" often depends on regional preferences, context, and the intended degree of formality or emphasis.
Comparison Chart
Traditional Usage
First person for future, obligation
Intention, prediction, future
ADVERTISEMENT
Modern Usage (US)
Formality, obligation
Common future marker
British English
Offers/suggestions in questions
Seeking information about the future
Indication of
Obligation or formality
Intention or prediction
Context
More formal, often seen in legal contexts
More widely used, especially in American Eng
Compare with Definitions
Shall
An auxiliary verb used to indicate a future action.
I shall go to the store tomorrow.
Will
Indicates intention or voluntary action.
She will help with the project.
Shall
To express an obligation or command.
You shall not pass.
Will
Expresses a prediction or an expectation.
It will rain tomorrow.
Shall
Used in questions to offer or suggest.
Shall we begin?
Will
Used to express capability or capacity.
This bottle will hold two liters.
Shall
Denotes determination in some contexts.
We shall overcome the challenges.
Will
The mental faculty by which one deliberately chooses or decides upon a course of action
Championed freedom of will against a doctrine of predetermination.
Shall
Used before a verb to indicate the simple future tense in the first person singular or plural.
I shall sing in the choir tomorrow.
I hope that we shall win the game.
Will
Diligent purposefulness; determination
An athlete with the will to win.
Shall
Used similarly to indicate determination or obligation in the second and third persons singular or plural.
(determination): You shall go to the ball!
(obligation): Citizens shall provide proof of identity.
Will
Self-control; self-discipline
Lacked the will to overcome the addiction.
Shall
Used in questions with the first person singular or plural to suggest a possible future action.
Shall I help you with that?
Shall we go out later?
Let us examine that, shall we?
Will
A desire, purpose, or determination, especially of one in authority
It is the sovereign's will that the prisoner be spared.
Shall
(obsolete) To owe.
Will
Deliberate intention or wish
Let it be known that I took this course of action against my will.
Shall
To owe; to be under obligation for.
Will
Free discretion; inclination or pleasure
Wandered about, guided only by will.
Shall
To be obliged; must.
Will
Bearing or attitude toward others; disposition
Full of good will.
Shall
A word indicating inevitability or certain prediction.
They shall regret their decisions.
Will
A legal declaration of how a person wishes their personal possessions to be disposed of after death.
Will
A legally executed document containing this declaration.
Will
To decide on or intend
He can finish the race if he wills it.
Will
To yearn for; desire
“She makes you will your own destruction” (George Bernard Shaw).
Will
To decree, dictate, or order
Believed that the outcome was willed by the gods.
Will
To induce or try to induce by sheer force of will
We willed the sun to come out.
Will
To grant in a legal will; bequeath
Willed his fortune to charity.
Will
To order to direct in a legal will
She willed that her money be given to charity.
Will
To exercise the will.
Will
To make a choice; choose
Do as you will.
Will
To wish; desire
Do what you will. Sit here if you will. See Usage Note at shall.
Will
(auxiliary) Used to express the future tense, sometimes with some implication of volition when used in the first person. Compare shall.
One of our salesmen will visit you tomorrow.
I will pass this exam.
Will
(auxiliary) To be able to, to have the capacity to.
Unfortunately, only one of these gloves will actually fit over my hand.
Will
(auxiliary) Expressing a present tense with some conditional or subjective weakening: "will turn out to", "must by inference".
He will be home by now. He always gets home before 6 o'clock.
I can't find my umbrella. I will have forgotten it home this morning.
Will
(auxiliary) To habitually do (a given action).
Boys will be boys.
Will
(auxiliary) To choose or agree to (do something); used to express intention but without any temporal connotations (+ bare infinitive), often in questions and negation.
Will you marry me?
I’ve told him three times, but he won’t take his medicine.
Will
To wish, desire (something).
Do what you will.
Will
To wish or desire (that something happen); to intend (that).
Will
(archaic) Implying will go.
Will
To instruct (that something be done) in one's will.
Will
(transitive) To bequeath (something) to someone in one's will (legal document).
He willed his stamp collection to the local museum.
Will
(transitive) To exert one's force of will (intention) in order to compel, or attempt to compel, something to happen or someone to do something.
All the fans were willing their team to win the game.
Will
One's independent faculty of choice; the ability to be able to exercise one's choice or intention.
Of course, man's will is often regulated by his reason.
Will
The act of choosing to do something; a person’s conscious intent or volition.
Most creatures have a will to live.
Will
One's intention or decision; someone's orders or commands.
Eventually I submitted to my parents' will.
Will
Firmity of purpose, fixity of intent
Will
(law) A formal declaration of one's intent concerning the disposal of one's property and holdings after death; the legal document stating such wishes.
Will
(archaic) That which is desired; one's wish.
Will
(archaic) Desire, longing. (Now generally merged with later senses.)
He felt a great will to make a pilgrimage to the Holy Land.
Will
The power of choosing; the faculty or endowment of the soul by which it is capable of choosing; the faculty or power of the mind by which we decide to do or not to do; the power or faculty of preferring or selecting one of two or more objects.
It is necessary to form a distinct notion of what is meant by the word "volition" in order to understand the import of the word will, for this last word expresses the power of mind of which "volition" is the act.
Will is an ambiguous word, being sometimes put for the faculty of willing; sometimes for the act of that faculty, besides [having] other meanings. But "volition" always signifies the act of willing, and nothing else.
Appetite is the will's solicitor, and the will is appetite's controller; what we covet according to the one, by the other we often reject.
The will is plainly that by which the mind chooses anything.
Will
The choice which is made; a determination or preference which results from the act or exercise of the power of choice; a volition.
The word "will," however, is not always used in this its proper acceptation, but is frequently substituted for "volition", as when I say that my hand mover in obedience to my will.
Will
The choice or determination of one who has authority; a decree; a command; discretionary pleasure.
Thy will be done.
Our prayers should be according to the will of God.
Will
Strong wish or inclination; desire; purpose.
My poverty, but not my will, consents; . . . Put this in any liquid thing you will,And drink it off.
Will
That which is strongly wished or desired.
What's your will, good friar?
The mariner hath his will.
Will
Arbitrary disposal; power to control, dispose, or determine.
Deliver me not over unto the will of mine enemies.
Will
The legal declaration of a person's mind as to the manner in which he would have his property or estate disposed of after his death; the written instrument, legally executed, by which a man makes disposition of his estate, to take effect after his death; testament; devise. See the Note under Testament, 1.
Will
To wish; to desire; to incline to have.
A wife as of herself no thing ne sholde [should]Wille in effect, but as her husband wolde [would].
Caleb said unto her, What will thou ?
They would none of my counsel.
Will
As an auxiliary, will is used to denote futurity dependent on the verb. Thus, in first person, "I will" denotes willingness, consent, promise; and when "will" is emphasized, it denotes determination or fixed purpose; as, I will go if you wish; I will go at all hazards. In the second and third persons, the idea of distinct volition, wish, or purpose is evanescent, and simple certainty is appropriately expressed; as, "You will go," or "He will go," describes a future event as a fact only. To emphasize will denotes (according to the tone or context) certain futurity or fixed determination.
I am able to devote as much time and attention to other subjects as I will [shall] be under the necessity of doing next winter.
A countryman, telling us what he had seen, remarked that if the conflagration went on, as it was doing, we would [should] have, as our next season's employment, the Old Town of Edinburgh to rebuild.
I feel assured that I will [shall] not have the misfortune to find conflicting views held by one so enlightened as your excellency.
Will
To be willing; to be inclined or disposed; to be pleased; to wish; to desire.
And behold, there came a leper and worshiped him, saying, Lord if thou wilt, thou canst make me clean. And Jesus . . . touched him, saying, I will; be thou clean.
Will
To form a distinct volition of; to determine by an act of choice; to ordain; to decree.
By all law and reason, that which the Parliament will not, is no more established in this kingdom.
Two things he [God] willeth, that we should be good, and that we should be happy.
Will
To enjoin or command, as that which is determined by an act of volition; to direct; to order.
They willed me say so, madam.
Send for music,And will the cooks to use their best of cunningTo please the palate.
As you go, will the lord mayor . . . To attend our further pleasure presently.
Will
To give or direct the disposal of by testament; to bequeath; to devise; as, to will one's estate to a child; also, to order or direct by testament; as, he willed that his nephew should have his watch.
Will
To exercise an act of volition; to choose; to decide; to determine; to decree.
At Winchester he lies, so himself willed.
He that shall turn his thoughts inward upon what passes in his own mind when he wills.
I contend for liberty as it signifies a power in man to do as he wills or pleases.
Will
The capability of conscious choice and decision and intention;
The exercise of their volition we construe as revolt
Will
A fixed and persistent intent or purpose;
Where there's a will there's a way
Will
A legal document declaring a person's wishes regarding the disposal of their property when they die
Will
Decree or ordain;
God wills our existence
Will
Have in mind;
I will take the exam tomorrow
Will
Determine by choice;
This action was willed and intended
Will
Leave or give by will after one's death;
My aunt bequeathed me all her jewelry
My grandfather left me his entire estate
Will
An auxiliary verb to express the future tense.
I will visit my grandparents next week.
Will
Indicates habitual action.
He will jog every morning.
Common Curiosities
Can "will" and "shall" be used interchangeably?
While they both can indicate the future, their nuances can differ based on region and context.
Is "shall" outdated in American English?
"Shall" is less common and is often considered formal in American English.
How do British English speakers use "shall" in questions?
They might use "shall" for offers or suggestions, as in "Shall we go?"
Which is more commonly used in legal documents?
"Shall" is often used in legal contexts to denote obligation.
Is "shall" more obligatory than "will"?
In modern usage, "shall" can indicate a stronger sense of obligation or formality.
Is "will" always about the future?
Mostly, but "will" can also indicate capability, intention, or habitual actions.
Are there regions where "shall" is still prevalent?
Yes, in parts of the UK and other regions, "shall" retains a more distinct usage.
Can "will" indicate a voluntary action?
Yes, "will" can express an intentional or voluntary action.
How did traditional rules dictate the use of "shall" and "will"?
Traditionally, "shall" was used with the first person for future actions, while "will" indicated determination.
Which is more formal, "shall" or "will"?
"Shall" is generally considered more formal, especially in American English.
Share Your Discovery
Previous Comparison
Wrap vs. BurritoNext Comparison
Renter vs. TenantAuthor Spotlight
Written by
Tayyaba RehmanTayyaba Rehman is a distinguished writer, currently serving as a primary contributor to askdifference.com. As a researcher in semantics and etymology, Tayyaba's passion for the complexity of languages and their distinctions has found a perfect home on the platform. Tayyaba delves into the intricacies of language, distinguishing between commonly confused words and phrases, thereby providing clarity for readers worldwide.