Shortlist vs. Downselect — What's the Difference?
By Tayyaba Rehman — Updated on November 5, 2023
A shortlist is a narrowed list of candidates or options, while downselect refers to the act of reducing choices to a final selection.
Difference Between Shortlist and Downselect
Table of Contents
ADVERTISEMENT
Key Differences
A shortlist generally refers to a selection of preferred candidates or options out of a larger group, typically the result of an initial screening process. Downselect, a less commonly used term, often involves a more active process of eliminating options to make a final decision. Shortlists are used in contexts like job hiring or award nominations, where many candidates are narrowed down to the most suitable few. Conversely, downselect is often found in specialized contexts like procurement or technical evaluations, where the choices are systematically reduced.
When someone creates a shortlist, they have identified the most promising candidates but have not yet made a final choice. Downselecting usually signifies that the choices have been scrutinized in detail, and a final selection is imminent or has been made. The shortlist is often shared with stakeholders for further input, while downselecting is typically followed by negotiations or finalizing a deal. Being shortlisted means you are among a preferred group, but being downselected suggests you are the top choice or one of the very few remaining options.
In summary, shortlisting is a step in the selection process, while downselecting is closer to the conclusion of that process. Shortlists might be revised and reviewed multiple times, but downselection is usually a one-time, decisive move towards a final decision. Shortlisting is a more familiar term in everyday use, applicable to various scenarios, while downselect is a more technical term, used in specific industries or contexts.
Comparison Chart
Definition
A list of candidates selected from a larger group for further consideration.
The act of further reducing a shortlist to a final choice or a smaller, more refined list.
Stage of Selection
Preliminary stage, before final decisions.
Closer to the final stage of decision-making.
ADVERTISEMENT
Frequency of Use
Common in everyday contexts.
More technical, used in specific contexts.
Process
Involves identifying a group of preferred options.
Involves actively eliminating options to finalize a decision.
Connotation
Implies possibility and potential for final selection.
Suggests finality and a closer step to concluding the selection.
Compare with Definitions
Shortlist
A narrowed down list for further consideration.
After reviewing submissions, the judges announced the shortlist.
Downselect
Final stage of a selection process.
She was eager to learn who would be downselected for the fellowship.
Shortlist
A group selected as most likely to succeed.
The investor had a shortlist of startups he believed had potential.
Downselect
To reduce choices to a final selection.
The agency will downselect to one contractor by next month.
Shortlist
A list of selected candidates deemed suitable for a position.
She was thrilled to make the shortlist for the scholarship.
Downselect
The act of choosing the final option.
After much deliberation, they began to downselect from five proposals.
Shortlist
Preferred options chosen from a larger group.
The committee created a shortlist of locations for the event.
Downselect
To narrow down options based on rigorous criteria.
The engineers will downselect the material suppliers based on quality tests.
Shortlist
To place in a list for subsequent review.
His novel was shortlisted for a prestigious literary award.
Downselect
To eliminate alternatives to make a decision.
The panel is ready to downselect a winner from the finalists.
Shortlist
A list of selected candidates from which a final choice is made
A shortlist of four companies
Downselect
To narrow the field of choices, especially, to choose a supplier from candidates under consideration
We need to check with Quality Assurance before we downselect the test equipment vendor.
Shortlist
Put (someone or something) on a shortlist
The novel was shortlisted for the Booker Prize
Shortlist
A list of preferable items or candidates that have been selected for final consideration, as in making an award or filling a position.
Shortlist
Alternative spelling of short list
Shortlist
To place something on a short list
Shortlist
Put someone or something on a short list
Common Curiosities
Can organizations downselect without a shortlist?
It's possible, but usually, there's a shortlist first.
Can a shortlist have only one option?
Typically no, a shortlist implies multiple candidates or options.
Is shortlisting the same as downselecting?
No, shortlisting is creating a list of top candidates, downselecting is choosing the final option(s).
What follows after downselecting?
Typically, a final decision, contract, or announcement.
Can anyone create a shortlist?
Yes, individuals or organizations can create shortlists.
Do you downselect from a shortlist?
Yes, downselecting often means choosing from a shortlist.
Is being shortlisted a guarantee of being chosen?
No, it means you're under consideration but not yet chosen.
Does downselecting involve interviews?
It can, especially if it's part of a hiring process.
Can downselect be used in everyday language?
It's usually used in technical or business contexts.
How specific is a downselect?
Very specific, often narrowing down to one final choice.
Can shortlists be made public?
Yes, especially for awards or job postings.
Is a shortlist binding?
No, it's a list for consideration, not a final commitment.
Can the process of downselecting be reversed?
Typically not, as it's a move toward a final decision.
Are shortlists always formal?
Not always; they can be informal lists too.
Is downselect a common term outside of business?
No, it's not commonly used outside of business or technical fields.
Share Your Discovery
Previous Comparison
Dart vs. Arrow
Next Comparison
Cop vs. DropAuthor Spotlight
Written by
Tayyaba RehmanTayyaba Rehman is a distinguished writer, currently serving as a primary contributor to askdifference.com. As a researcher in semantics and etymology, Tayyaba's passion for the complexity of languages and their distinctions has found a perfect home on the platform. Tayyaba delves into the intricacies of language, distinguishing between commonly confused words and phrases, thereby providing clarity for readers worldwide.
