Supernatant vs. Decantation — What's the Difference?
By Tayyaba Rehman & Maham Liaqat — Updated on April 27, 2024
Supernatant is the clear liquid remaining above a solid or precipitate after settling or centrifugation, while decantation is the process of pouring this liquid off.
Difference Between Supernatant and Decantation
Table of Contents
ADVERTISEMENT
Key Differences
Supernatant refers to the clear liquid layer that remains on top after a mixture has settled or has been centrifuged, indicating a state rather than an action. On the other hand, decantation is the method used to separate this supernatant from the precipitate or heavier sediments, emphasizing the procedural aspect of handling such mixtures.
While supernatant is typically seen in laboratory settings, such as in chemistry and biology to describe the fluid above sediments or cells after centrifugation or settling, decantation is a broader technique used not only in labs but also in everyday scenarios such as separating oil from water or wine from its sediments.
The quality of the supernatant can vary based on the amount of particulate matter initially present and the effectiveness of the settling or centrifugation process. Conversely, the effectiveness of decantation largely depends on the skill of the person performing it and the contrast in density between the liquid and solid components.
Supernatant can also be further processed or analyzed after separation, which is crucial in experimental and diagnostic procedures. On the other hand, decantation is often just one step in a sequence of processes aimed at purifying a substance or preparing it for further analysis or use.
In practical applications, the clarity and purity of the supernatant are critical, particularly in chemical synthesis and analytical testing. Decantation must be carefully managed to avoid disturbing the sediment layer, which could compromise the purity of the separated liquid.
ADVERTISEMENT
Comparison Chart
Definition
Clear liquid above a sediment
Process of pouring off the supernatant
Primary Use
Description in labs and processes
Technique used in labs and everyday life
Dependence
Quality depends on settling process
Success depends on technique and density contrast
Subsequent Use
Often further processed or analyzed
Usually a preparatory or purifying step
Importance of Clarity
Essential for analysis and use
Crucial for effective separation
Compare with Definitions
Supernatant
Used in both biological and chemical lab settings.
The supernatant contained the enzymes crucial for the experiment.
Decantation
Can be used in everyday cooking, such as separating fat from broth.
She used decantation to remove the oil from the top of the soup.
Supernatant
Describes the fluid part of a sample after processing.
The supernatant was then subjected to further analysis.
Decantation
Commonly used in chemistry to separate mixtures.
Decantation was crucial in purifying the chemical solution.
Supernatant
In clinical settings, refers to the clear part of blood after centrifugation.
The lab technician examined the supernatant for any signs of contamination.
Decantation
A primary step in various industrial processes.
Decantation is used in the water treatment process to remove particulates.
Supernatant
Can indicate purity or the presence of soluble substances.
The clarity of the supernatant suggested that the reaction was complete.
Decantation
The process of gently pouring a liquid from a container leaving sediment behind.
He performed decantation to separate the wine from its sediment.
Supernatant
The clear liquid remaining above the precipitate after settling or centrifugation.
The researcher carefully pipetted the supernatant for testing.
Decantation
Often requires careful handling to maintain separation.
During the decantation, he avoided disturbing the settled particles.
Supernatant
Denoting the liquid lying above a solid residue after crystallization, precipitation, centrifugation, or other process
Carefully transfer the supernatant fluid into a 15 ml centrifuge tube
Decantation
Decantation is a process for the separation of mixtures of immiscible liquids or of a liquid and a solid mixture such as a suspension. The layer closer to the top of the container—the less dense of the two liquids, or the liquid from which the precipitate or sediment has settled out—is poured off, leaving the other component or the more dense liquid of the mixture behind.
Supernatant
A volume of supernatant liquid
The supernatants were filtered and analysed
Decantation
To pour off (wine, for example) without disturbing the sediment.
Supernatant
Floating on the surface.
Decantation
To pour (a liquid) from one container into another.
Supernatant
The clear fluid above a sediment or precipitate.
Decantation
To aerate (a wine) by pouring it into a spacious vessel and leaving it exposed to the air for a period of time
Decanted the wine for twenty minutes before serving.
Supernatant
Lying or floating above a denser fluid, or above a solid sediment or precipitate (which has been separated by crystallisation, centrifugation etc.).
Decantation
The act of decanting the supernatant liquid from a solid sediment
Supernatant
The liquid that lies above a sediment or precipitate; supernate
Decantation
The act of pouring off a clear liquor gently from its lees or sediment, or from one vessel into another.
Supernatant
Material that floats on the surface of a liquid
Supernatant
Swimming above; floating on the surface; as, oil supernatant on water.
Supernatant
The liquid remaining after solids suspended in the liquid have been sedimented by gravity or by centrifugation. Contrasted with the solid sediment, or (in centrifugation) the pellet.
Supernatant
A liquid lying above a sediment (floating on the surface)
Supernatant
Of a liquid; floating on the surface above a sediment or precipitate;
The supernatant fat was skimmed off
Common Curiosities
What is the importance of the clarity of the supernatant in scientific experiments?
Clarity indicates the absence of suspended particulates, which is crucial for the accuracy of chemical and biological analyses.
Where is decantation commonly used?
Decantation is used in laboratories, in cooking (e.g., separating fat from broths), and in industrial processes like water treatment.
What is decantation?
Decantation is the process of carefully pouring off the liquid (supernatant) while leaving the sediment behind.
How does the density of materials affect decantation?
The greater the density difference between the liquid and solid, the more effective the decantation process.
What tools are typically used for decantation?
Simple containers like beakers and jars are used, sometimes aided by funnels to control the flow.
How does supernatant differ from decantation?
Supernatant is the liquid itself, while decantation is the method used to separate this liquid from the sediment.
What is supernatant?
Supernatant is the clear liquid layer that remains after a liquid-solid mixture has settled or been centrifuged.
How long should a mixture sit before decanting?
This depends on the particle size and the viscosity of the liquid; larger, heavier particles settle faster.
Why is decantation important in wine making?
It removes sediment that can affect the flavor and appearance of the wine.
What types of mixtures can be separated by decantation?
Mixtures of liquids and solids or two immiscible liquids (e.g., oil and water) can be separated by decantation.
Is supernatant always discarded after experiments?
Not necessarily; the supernatant may contain valuable solutes and can be further analyzed or used in subsequent steps of an experiment.
Can decantation be automated in industrial processes?
Yes, many industries automate decantation to handle large volumes and improve the efficiency and safety of the separation process.
Can decantation separate all types of solids from liquids?
Decantation is best for coarse, heavy solids that settle easily. Fine or colloidal particles may require other methods like filtration.
Can decantation be used to purify water?
Yes, it's a preliminary step in water treatment processes to remove large particulates.
What precautions should be taken during decantation?
Care must be taken not to disturb the sediment, and appropriate tools should be used to ensure a clean separation.
Share Your Discovery
Previous Comparison
Half vs. Halves
Next Comparison
Design vs. DraftingAuthor Spotlight
Written by
Tayyaba RehmanTayyaba Rehman is a distinguished writer, currently serving as a primary contributor to askdifference.com. As a researcher in semantics and etymology, Tayyaba's passion for the complexity of languages and their distinctions has found a perfect home on the platform. Tayyaba delves into the intricacies of language, distinguishing between commonly confused words and phrases, thereby providing clarity for readers worldwide.
Co-written by
Maham Liaqat
