Surrealism vs. Fantasy — What's the Difference?
Edited by Tayyaba Rehman — By Maham Liaqat — Updated on May 9, 2024
Surrealism blends the real and the dreamlike, focusing on illogical scenes and juxtapositions driven by the unconscious mind, while fantasy creates entire worlds governed by their own unique, often magical, rules.
Difference Between Surrealism and Fantasy
Table of Contents
ADVERTISEMENT
Key Differences
Surrealism, an artistic and literary movement originating in the early 20th century, emphasizes the irrational and the role of the unconscious, often employing bizarre scenes and dream-like sequences. Whereas, fantasy is a genre of fiction that involves the creation of supernatural and mythical beings in worlds often completely detached from realistic human experiences.
Artists in surrealism, such as Salvador Dalí and René Magritte, create art that defies conventional logic through unexpected combinations and dream-inspired scenes, aiming to challenge the viewer's perception and conventional reality. On the other hand, fantasy authors like J.R.R. Tolkien and J.K. Rowling construct elaborate narratives with fully developed worlds, distinct laws of nature, and often an epic battle between good and evil.
Surrealism seeks to explore the human psyche and express the workings of the mind through visual and written media, suggesting a deeper reality beyond the mundane. In contrast, fantasy serves often to provide escapism, adventure, and the exploration of themes of heroism, power, and morality through its narrative.
The techniques in surrealism involve automatism, collage, and the inclusion of uncanny elements that create a sense of confusion between reality and dream. Conversely, fantasy utilizes detailed world-building, mythical creatures, and magical systems to captivate its audience and create immersive experiences.
While surrealism often presents a distorted view of the real world meant to provoke thought and introspection about the human condition, fantasy provides a narrative experience that, while completely detached from reality, resonates with real human emotions and conflicts through its allegorical and often moral storytelling.
ADVERTISEMENT
Comparison Chart
Origin
Early 20th century
Various historical origins, modern form popularized in the 20th century
Focus
Unconscious mind, dreams, and irrationality
Mythical beings, magical worlds, heroism
Purpose
Challenge reality, explore psychological depth
Entertain, provide escapism, explore moral questions
Techniques
Automatism, bizarre juxtapositions, collage
Elaborate world-building, magical elements, epic narratives
Representation
Real world in an unreal way
Completely invented worlds and laws
Compare with Definitions
Surrealism
An artistic movement that seeks to release the creative potential of the unconscious mind.
A surrealism painting might depict a clock melting over a tree branch, challenging notions of time and reality.
Fantasy
Focuses on good vs. evil conflicts, heroism, and moral dilemmas.
Fantasy stories typically revolve around a protagonist's journey to overcome evil forces.
Surrealism
Characterized by illogical scenes and bizarre juxtapositions.
In surrealism, you might see a fish wearing a bowler hat walking down the street.
Fantasy
Includes extensive world-building to provide a backdrop for the narrative.
Fantasy authors spend considerable time developing the history, geography, and cultures of their imagined worlds.
Surrealism
Aims to explore ideas beyond rational understanding.
Surrealist literature may include narratives that defy linear storytelling and logic.
Fantasy
A genre of fiction involving magical or supernatural forces and beings.
Fantasy novels often feature wizards, dragons, and quests.
Surrealism
Influences a variety of media, including painting, sculpture, and film.
Surrealism has influenced filmmakers to explore dreams and subconscious narratives in their works.
Fantasy
Creates worlds where magic is often a common element.
In a fantasy world, magic can be used for healing, combat, or everyday convenience.
Surrealism
Often involves the element of surprise and unexpected connections.
Surrealism art often surprises its viewers by combining objects in unexpected ways.
Fantasy
Appeals to all age groups, providing a universal form of storytelling.
Fantasy is enjoyed by children and adults alike, offering stories that resonate with a wide audience.
Surrealism
Surrealism was a cultural movement which developed in Europe in the aftermath of World War I and was largely influenced by Dada. The movement is best known for its visual artworks and writings and the juxtaposition of distant realities to activate the unconscious mind through the imagery.
Fantasy
Fantasy is a genre of speculative fiction set in a fictional universe, often inspired by real world myth and folklore. Its roots are in oral traditions, which then became fantasy literature and drama.
Surrealism
A literary and artistic movement of the 1900s that attempts to express the workings of the subconscious and is characterized by fantastic imagery and incongruous juxtaposition of subject matter.
Fantasy
The faculty or activity of imagining impossible or improbable things
His researches had moved into the realms of fantasy
A fantasy world
Surrealism
Literature or art produced in this style.
Fantasy
A fantasia.
Surrealism
An artistic movement and an aesthetic philosophy that aims for the liberation of the mind by emphasizing the critical and imaginative powers of the subconscious.
Fantasy
Imagine the occurrence of; fantasize about
It is ludicrous to fantasy ‘disinventing’ the hydrogen bomb
Surrealism
A 20th century movement of artists and writers (developing out of Dadaism) who used fantastic images and incongruous juxtapositions in order to represent unconscious thoughts and dreams
Fantasy
The creative imagination; unrestrained fancy.
Fantasy
Something, such as an invention, that is a creation of the fancy.
Fantasy
A capricious or fantastic idea; a conceit.
Fantasy
A genre of fiction or other artistic work characterized by fanciful or supernatural elements.
Fantasy
A work of this genre.
Fantasy
An imagined event or sequence of mental images, such as a daydream, usually fulfilling a wish or psychological need.
Fantasy
An unrealistic or improbable supposition.
Fantasy
(Music) See fantasia.
Fantasy
A coin issued especially by a questionable authority and not intended for use as currency.
Fantasy
(Obsolete) A hallucination.
Fantasy
Relating to or being a game in which participants act as owners of imaginary sports teams whose personnel consists of actual players selected from a professional sports league and team performance is determined by the combined statistics of the players.
Fantasy
To imagine; visualize.
Fantasy
That which comes from one's imagination.
Fantasy
(literature) The literary genre generally dealing with themes of magic and the supernatural, imaginary worlds and creatures, etc.
Fantasy
A fantastical design.
Fantasy
(slang) The drug gamma-hydroxybutyric acid.
Fantasy
To fantasize (about).
Fantasy
(obsolete) To have a fancy for; to be pleased with; to like.
Fantasy
(transitive) To imagine; to conceive mentally.
Fantasy
Fancy; imagination; especially, a whimsical or fanciful conception; a vagary of the imagination; whim; caprice; humor.
Is not this something more than fantasy ?
A thousand fantasiesBegin to throng into my memory.
Fantasy
Fantastic designs.
Embroidered with fantasies and flourishes of gold thread.
Fantasy
To have a fancy for; to be pleased with; to like; to fancy.
Which he doth most fantasy.
Fantasy
Imagination unrestricted by reality;
A schoolgirl fantasy
Fantasy
Fiction with a large amount of fantasy in it;
She made a lot of money writing romantic fantasies
Fantasy
Something many people believe that is false;
They have the illusion that I am very wealthy
Common Curiosities
How do surrealism and fantasy differ in their depiction of the unreal?
Surrealism distorts the real to explore the unconscious, whereas fantasy invents new realities rooted in magic and myth.
Can elements of surrealism be found in fantasy?
Yes, surreal elements can appear in fantasy, especially in the depiction of dreams or otherworldly realms.
How do artists and writers of surrealism and fantasy differ in their creative process?
Surrealism often employs spontaneous techniques to bypass conscious thought, while fantasy writers meticulously craft worlds and plots.
What impact did surrealism and fantasy have on culture?
Surrealism had a profound impact on modern art and psychoanalysis, while fantasy has hugely influenced popular entertainment and literature.
Why might someone choose to explore surrealism instead of fantasy?
Someone interested in deeper psychological and philosophical exploration might prefer surrealism's focus on the unconscious mind's workings.
What educational value do surrealism and fantasy offer?
Surrealism can enhance understanding of psychology and the arts, while fantasy can stimulate imagination and moral reasoning.
How have surrealism and fantasy evolved over the years?
Surrealism has permeated various art forms and influenced contemporary art, while fantasy has grown with new subgenres and media adaptations.
Which is more focused on emotional impact, surrealism or fantasy?
Both aim for emotional impact but in different ways: surrealism through psychological exploration and fantasy through narrative resonance.
How do audiences typically respond to surrealism compared to fantasy?
Audiences might find surrealism challenging and thought-provoking, while fantasy often provides more direct entertainment and escapism.
Are there any hybrid genres that combine elements of both surrealism and fantasy?
Yes, some works blend the imaginative aspects of fantasy with the psychological depth of surrealism, creating uniquely immersive experiences.
Share Your Discovery
Previous Comparison
Gruel vs. OatmealNext Comparison
Sucralose vs. XylitolAuthor Spotlight
Written by
Maham LiaqatEdited by
Tayyaba RehmanTayyaba Rehman is a distinguished writer, currently serving as a primary contributor to askdifference.com. As a researcher in semantics and etymology, Tayyaba's passion for the complexity of languages and their distinctions has found a perfect home on the platform. Tayyaba delves into the intricacies of language, distinguishing between commonly confused words and phrases, thereby providing clarity for readers worldwide.