Whistle vs. Catcall — What's the Difference?
Edited by Tayyaba Rehman — By Maham Liaqat — Updated on April 23, 2024
A whistle is a simple, sharp sound made by forcing air through pursed lips or a device, often used as a signal or to attract attention, while a catcall is a loud whistle or comment to express attraction or appraisal, typically considered disrespectful.
Difference Between Whistle and Catcall
Table of Contents
ADVERTISEMENT
Key Differences
A whistle can be produced by a person or through a mechanical device, serving various purposes like signaling, calling for attention, or used in sports and training. Whereas, a catcall specifically involves making a whistle or remark to express any attraction or appraisal, often unsolicited and viewed negatively.
Whistles are generally neutral and can be seen in positive contexts such as sports officiating or personal safety. On the other hand, catcalls are usually perceived as inappropriate and disrespectful, reflecting societal issues around harassment and gender respect.
While whistles can be taught and used deliberately in scenarios like training animals or coordinating actions in team sports, catcalls are spontaneous and typically aimed at strangers, primarily in public settings.
The cultural reception of whistles varies widely; they are often considered practical and necessary in many professional and recreational activities. In contrast, catcalls are increasingly condemned as disrespectful and demeaning, particularly in social movements advocating for women's rights and dignity.
In terms of regulation, whistles are encouraged or required in certain settings for safety and order, such as in lifeguarding or in traffic control. Catcalls, however, are often subject to societal disapproval and legal measures in some places to combat street harassment.
ADVERTISEMENT
Comparison Chart
Definition
A sound made by forcing air through lips or a device.
A loud whistle or remark that is gender suggestive.
Usage
Signaling, attention-getting, or as part of a job.
Expressing attraction or appraisal, typically unsolicited.
Perception
Neutral or positive, depending on context.
Generally negative and considered disrespectful.
Contexts
Sports, training, safety.
Street harassment, unsolicited remarks.
Cultural and Legal Reception
Often required and regulated for safety.
Increasingly condemned and sometimes legally restricted.
Compare with Definitions
Whistle
Often associated with sports and training activities.
The referee’s whistle signaled the end of the match.
Catcall
A loud, suggestive call or comment directed at someone.
She ignored the catcall from across the street.
Whistle
A sound used for signaling or calling attention.
The coach blew his whistle to start the game.
Catcall
Often used to express unsolicited interest.
The construction workers were reprimanded for catcalling pedestrians.
Whistle
Can be produced manually or with a mechanical device.
She carried a safety whistle on her keychain.
Catcall
Can lead to discomfort and is considered disrespectful.
She felt uncomfortable due to the frequent catcalls in that area.
Whistle
Used in various contexts for communication or warning.
The lifeguard used his whistle to alert the swimmers.
Catcall
Viewed negatively as a form of street harassment.
Movements against street harassment aim to eliminate catcalls.
Whistle
Regulated in certain professional settings.
Traffic police use a whistle for better control at intersections.
Catcall
Sometimes subject to legal restrictions.
Some cities have laws against catcalling to protect public safety.
Whistle
A whistle is an instrument which produces sound from a stream of gas, most commonly air. It may be mouth-operated, or powered by air pressure, steam, or other means.
Catcall
A harsh or shrill call or whistle expressing derision or disapproval.
Whistle
To produce a clear musical sound by forcing air through the teeth or through an aperture formed by pursing the lips.
Catcall
To express derision or disapproval of with catcalls.
Whistle
To produce a clear, shrill, sharp musical sound by passing air over or through an opening
The tea kettle whistled on the stove.
Catcall
To make catcalls.
Whistle
To produce a high-pitched sound when moving swiftly through the air
The stone whistled past my head.
Catcall
A shout or whistle expressing dislike, especially from a crowd or audience; a jeer, a boo.
Whistle
To produce a high-pitched sound by the rapid movement of air through an opening or past an obstruction
Wind whistled through the cracks in the windows.
Catcall
(historical) A whistle blown by a theatre-goer to express disapproval.
Whistle
To emit a shrill, sharp, high-pitched cry, as some birds and other animals.
Catcall
(programming) In the Eiffel programming language, a run-time error caused by use of the wrong data type.
Whistle
To produce by whistling
Whistle a tune.
Catcall
To make such an exclamation.
Whistle
To summon, signal, or direct by whistling
I whistled down a cab. The referee whistled that the play was dead.
Catcall
A sound like the cry of a cat, such as is made in playhouses to express dissatisfaction with a play; also, a small shrill instrument for making such a noise.
Upon the rising of the curtain. I was very much surprised with the great consort of catcalls which was exhibited.
Whistle
(Sports) To signal a rule infraction committed by (a player).
Catcall
A cry expressing disapproval
Whistle
A small wind instrument for making whistling sounds by means of the breath.
Catcall
Utter catcalls at
Whistle
A device for making whistling sounds by means of forced air or steam
A factory whistle.
Whistle
A sound produced by a whistling device or by whistling through the lips.
Whistle
A whistling sound, as of an animal or projectile.
Whistle
A device designed to be placed in the mouth and blown, or driven by steam or some other mechanism, to make a whistling sound.
Whistle
An act of whistling.
Whistle
A shrill, high-pitched sound made by whistling.
Whistle
Any high-pitched sound similar to the sound made by whistling.
The whistle of the wind in the trees
Whistle
(Cockney rhyming slang) A suit (from whistle and flute).
Whistle
(colloquial) The mouth and throat; so called as being the organs of whistling.
Whistle
(ambitransitive) To make a shrill, high-pitched sound by forcing air through the mouth. To produce a whistling sound, restrictions to the flow of air are created using the teeth, tongue and lips.
Never whistle at a funeral.
She was whistling a happy tune.
Whistle
(ambitransitive) To make a similar sound by forcing air through a musical instrument or a pipe etc.
The steam train whistled as it passed by.
Whistle
(intransitive) To move in such a way as to create a whistling sound.
A bullet whistled past.
Whistle
(transitive) To send, signal, or call by a whistle.
Whistle
To make a kind of musical sound, or series of sounds, by forcing the breath through a small orifice formed by contracting the lips; also, to emit a similar sound, or series of notes, from the mouth or beak, as birds.
The weary plowman leaves the task of day,And, trudging homeward, whistles on the way.
Whistle
To make a shrill sound with a wind or steam instrument, somewhat like that made with the lips; to blow a sharp, shrill tone.
Whistle
To sound shrill, or like a pipe; to make a sharp, shrill sound; as, a bullet whistles through the air.
The wild winds whistle, and the billows roar.
Whistle
To form, utter, or modulate by whistling; as, to whistle a tune or an air.
Whistle
To send, signal, or call by a whistle.
He chanced to miss his dog; we stood still till he had whistled him up.
I 'ld whistle her off, and let her down the windTo prey at fortune.
Whistle
A sharp, shrill, more or less musical sound, made by forcing the breath through a small orifice of the lips, or through or instrument which gives a similar sound; the sound used by a sportsman in calling his dogs; the shrill note of a bird; as, the sharp whistle of a boy, or of a boatswain's pipe; the blackbird's mellow whistle.
Might we but hearThe folded flocks, penned in their wattled cotes, . . . Or whistle from the lodge.
The countryman could not forbear smiling, . . . and by that means lost his whistle.
They fear his whistle, and forsake the seas.
Whistle
The shrill sound made by wind passing among trees or through crevices, or that made by bullet, or the like, passing rapidly through the air; the shrill noise (much used as a signal, etc.) made by steam or gas escaping through a small orifice, or impinging against the edge of a metallic bell or cup.
Whistle
An instrument in which gas or steam forced into a cavity, or against a thin edge, produces a sound more or less like that made by one who whistles through the compressed lips; as, a child's whistle; a boatswain's whistle; a steam whistle (see Steam whistle, under Steam).
The bells she jingled, and the whistle blew.
Whistle
The mouth and throat; - so called as being the organs of whistling.
So was her jolly whistle well ywet.
Let's drink the other cup to wet our whistles.
Whistle
The sound made by something moving rapidly or by steam coming out of a small aperture
Whistle
The act of signalling (e.g., summoning) by whistling or blowing a whistle;
The whistle signalled the end of the game
Whistle
Acoustic device that forces air or steam against an edge or into a cavity and so produces a loud shrill sound
Whistle
An inexpensive fipple flute
Whistle
Make whistling sounds;
He lay there, snoring and whistling
Whistle
Move with, or as with, a whistling sound;
The bullets whistled past him
Whistle
Utter or express by whistling;
She whistled a melody
Whistle
Move, send, or bring as if by whistling;
Her optimism whistled away these worries
Whistle
Make a whining, ringing, or whistling sound;
The kettle was singing
The bullet sang past his ear
Whistle
Give a signal by whistling;
She whistled for her maid
Common Curiosities
What is a catcall?
A catcall is a loud whistle or suggestive remark made to express attraction, often considered inappropriate and disrespectful.
How can catcalling affect individuals?
Catcalling can lead to psychological distress, feeling unsafe, and a degraded public environment, especially for women.
What is a whistle?
A whistle is a sound created by blowing air through pursed lips or a device, used for signaling or attracting attention.
Can a whistle be used for safety purposes?
Yes, whistles are often used for safety purposes, such as by lifeguards, in personal safety devices, or in emergency signals.
How are whistles used in sports?
In sports, whistles are used by referees and coaches to start or stop play, indicate fouls, or manage game flow.
Why are catcalls viewed negatively?
Catcalls are viewed negatively as they often constitute unsolicited and unwelcome bad remarks, contributing to discomfort and harassment.
Is it appropriate to whistle in public?
Whistling in public is generally acceptable if used for legitimate purposes like signaling, but should be avoided if it disturbs others.
What is the purpose of a whistle in training animals?
Whistles are used in animal training to issue commands or cues due to their distinct and consistent sound.
What legal measures exist against catcalling?
Some regions have laws against catcalling that categorize it as a form of harassment or public nuisance.
Are there any educational programs to reduce catcalling?
Yes, several awareness and educational programs aim to educate about the implications of catcalling and promote respectful behavior.
Can catcalls be considered compliments?
While some might perceive catcalls as compliments, they are generally regarded as disrespectful and inappropriate.
How can one respond if subjected to catcalling?
Responses can vary from ignoring it, confronting the harasser safely, or reporting the incident to authorities if necessary.
How are catcalls and whistles similar and different?
Both can involve similar sounds, but their contexts differ greatly; whistles are broadly used for various purposes, while catcalls are specific to expressing unsolicited interest, often negatively received.
Why might some people use catcalls?
Some people use catcalls as a misguided form of expressing attraction, not understanding the negative impact it may have.
What should be done if witnessing someone being catcalled?
If safe to do so, offering support to the person being harassed and reporting the incident can be appropriate actions.
Share Your Discovery
Previous Comparison
Sweater vs. Jumper
Next Comparison
Penumbra vs. UmbraAuthor Spotlight
Written by
Maham Liaqat
Edited by
Tayyaba RehmanTayyaba Rehman is a distinguished writer, currently serving as a primary contributor to askdifference.com. As a researcher in semantics and etymology, Tayyaba's passion for the complexity of languages and their distinctions has found a perfect home on the platform. Tayyaba delves into the intricacies of language, distinguishing between commonly confused words and phrases, thereby providing clarity for readers worldwide.
